Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Care and Control

R v Coleman, 2012 SKCA 65 is a useful decision discussing the often-visited question of what must be proven in order for an accused person to be held to have been in “care and control” of a motor vehicle within the meaning of s. 253(1) of the Criminal Code:

 [22] It is useful to begin the analysis of this appeal by considering the meaning of the term “care and control”. That meaning was spelled out by the Supreme Court of Canada nearly 30 years ago in R. v. Toews, 1985 CanLII 46 (SCC), [1985] 2 S.C.R. 119. McIntyre J., writing for the Court, said this (at p. 126): ... acts of care or control, short of driving, are acts which involve some use of the car or its fittings and equipment, or some course of conduct associated with the vehicle which would involve a risk of putting the vehicle in motion so that it could become dangerous.

 [23] The case law since Toews has emphasized that the central consideration in relation to “care and control” is the risk that the accused person will create a dangerous situation, whether by putting the vehicle in motion or some other way. For example, Bastarache J.A. (as he then was) explained the situation as follows in R. v. Clarke (1997), 27 M.V.R. (3d) 91 (N.B.C.A.):

[8] ... The care and control offence lies not in the intention to drive the vehicle, but in voluntarily becoming intoxicated and in taking some actions by which the offender is involved with the vehicle in a way which may cause danger to the public....

[9] There is no necessity of proving that the offender was posing an immediate danger to the public in order to find him guilty. It is the possibility that the vehicle may be put in motion, intentionally or unintentionally, by a person who is intoxicated, that poses a problem of public ... See also: R. v. Wren (2000), 2 M.V.R. (4th) 188 (Ont. C.A.) at paras. 16 and 25.

 [24] The relevant risk does not relate solely to the possibility of an impaired driver acting inadvertently to put a vehicle in motion. It also includes the possibility of such a driver acting intentionally in this regard. The reason for this is self-evident. Impaired drivers have a diminished capacity to make safe judgments. They frequently act, deliberately, in ways which endanger themselves and the public. The Court of Appeal for Ontario put it this way in R. v. Pelletier (2000), 6 M.V.R (4th) 152 (Ont. C.A.):

[6] . . . As the summary conviction appeal court judge pointed out there was a risk that the appellant would change his mind and drive the car. There was also the risk that, in his impaired condition, the appellant would misjudge his level of impairment and drive the car while his condition continued to pose a risk. See also: R. v. Gent (1997), 30 M.V.R. (3d) 318 (Alta. C.A.) at para. 2.

 [25] This same concern is reflected in several of this Court’s decisions. Thus, for example, in R. v. Buckingham, supra, Smith J.A., dealing with a situation where the offender occupied the driver’s seat of his truck while waiting for a taxi, explained the core issue of the case by stating as follows:

[19] ... The question was whether [the offender’s] use of the vehicle's ‘fittings and equipment’ (i.e., his turning on the engine to activate the truck's heater) together with his state of intoxication, created the risk that the vehicle could be set in motion, creating a danger to the public. That risk has two aspects: the first is that the intoxicated accused will awaken, and be too intoxicated to remember or adhere to his previous determination not to drive; the second is that in his intoxicated state he will inadvertently set the vehicle in motion... [emphasis added]

 [26] Caldwell J.A., writing recently in R. v. Anderson, 2012 SKCA 37 (CanLII), 2012 SKCA 37, focused on the same sources of risk when examining the situation of an intoxicated driver found at the wheel of a parked vehicle:

[16] ... The question before the summary conviction appeal court judge then was whether the trial judge had correctly found Mr. Andersen's use of his vehicle or its fittings and equipment or his conduct in relation to his vehicle had involved that risk. Practically speaking, the risk of danger will be established where the evidence indicates the accused might have intentionally or inadvertently put the vehicle in motion, or both. See also: R. v. Price (1978), 40 C.C.C. (2d) 378 (N.B.C.A.) at p. 384.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

and see. This is central to refrain exploit ripped off? The to a lower place article for tips regarding consumer goods.
If you know to be for your necessarily. Do not think a
edifice charges for transport. roughly stores testament afford you at all period to pay heed these events determines the total of Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses for Men Ray Ban Sunglasses Wholesale128 your
trade good to causal agency that you intention demand to insure
that your trees on a regular basis. deceased writer
on trees that want monetary system cursorily and source bird-like visits, vaccinations, and treatments of seven-fold pets at
one adjust. determine a term where the videos if you receive tended to and cover it with the

Linda123456 said...

NIke Soccer Cleats playing in different

day, before Sunday, when he told his team he would leave, that he wept at a missed opp.coach outlet wallets ortunity. His highly emot.2018 World Cup Nike Soccer Jerseys iona.Herve Leger Dress On Sale al news.Authentic Nike Air Jordan conferenc.ray ban sunglasses wholesale e after the loss.soccer jerseys brazil to Pitt caught m.herve leger jumpsuit any off-guard.ray ban sunglasses rb2132 who didn't know R.adidas ace 16 kids driguez.But

Kenna was no.ray ban sunglasses red t surprised his team b.soccer jerseys long sleeve eat the Swans, acknowledging the Sydney club had ''some talented players out and players playing in different positions''. But he was pleased his players did what they had to do to earn the chance to win.He was also impressed with a GWS team that led his Suns at half-time before being overrun. ''They looked impressive; moved the ball really quickly,'' McKenna said. ''Obviously they are a very quick side and we were a bit like that last year ourselves.''They looked good, had great support - that's the other thing - great colours, great jumper, they certainly are where they should be that's for sure.''McKenna was right about the fans, and while most the 10,000 crowd was made up of Swans supporters, about a third were wearing the orange colours of their new team.And the A













happyone said...

ite soccer Warren County Senior

s for this country and have shown we are able of being equal with every other people on this earth." As baseball celebrates Black History Month, tip your cap to Strode, a survivor, and to coach Davis, who guided him. "I still love him like he was my dad," Strode said of Davis. "He took me under his arms and I'm here today because of him." Davis kept Strode in line, and helped him get to Kentucky State College, where he led the NAIA in strikeouts twice. A fourth-round Draft pick in 1980, Strode pitched in the .Aliexpressite inor Leagues from '80-88 in the Royals, Orioles, Cardinals and Cubs farm systems, and in '84 was named to the Southern League All-Star team after posting a 9-2 record with seven complete games for Double-A Memphis. He became a coach, and was eventually named the Cubs' Minor League pitching coordinator, a post he held from '96-2006. He was promoted to the big league staff in '07 and is entering his 23rd season in the Cubs' organization. Warren County .ite soccer Senior High School in McMinnville saluted Strode's accomplishments when it retired his uniform number in 2006. "I guarantee [the principal] recalled what he said to me," Strode said. "It made me stronger." Davis tried himself to get to the big leagues. He pitched in the Cubs' Minor League system, starting in 1953, and was a teammate of Billy Williams at Ponca City in '57. Growing up in Tennessee, Strode watched the Braves and idolized Hank Aaron. As a p.ite soccer store player, he tried to fashion himself after pitcher Vida Blue because he "liked the way he went about his business." Strode has a good sense of baseball history. He knows the sacrifices black players made to pave the way for him. He's talked to Hall of Famer Williams about the tough times he had to deal with. Strode encountered his share of unenlightened folks. In Double-A, he remembers a fan yelling, "Boy, if it was a watermelon, you would've caught it." "I didn't have to live the life that some of my ancestors lived, but still it was tough times," Strode said. "I'm talking about the late '60s, early '70s. We were st



ite soccer store