Monday, July 27, 2009

Gen. Barry McCaffrey on Breaking our Addiction to Prison

This is an American piece but worth reading in the Canadian context:

Our traditional justice system has been inadequate to the task of breaking the cycle of substance abuse and crime. Four out of every five offenses are committed by someone with a drug or alcohol problem; and we just keep locking them up!

In just the past 20 years alone, state prison systems have added 1 million new cells to incarcerate the 2.3 million adults now behind bars in the U.S. That's far more than any other country on the globe with 1 out of every 100 adult Americans currently serving time.1 Approximately one-half of these individuals are addicted to drugs or alcohol2 and most do not pose a serious threat to public safety.

Prison for these individuals has accomplished little to stem the tide of crime or substance abuse. Upon their release from prison, two thirds of drug abusers commit a new crime3 and virtually all relapse quickly to drug abuse.4 And yet, despite these disappointing figures national expenditures on corrections well exceed $60 billion annually.5 On average, states spend $65,000 per bed, per year to build new prisons and $23,876 per bed, per year to operate them. Despite the staggering cost to incarcerate these individuals, most return to their communities without treatment, without jobs and without hope.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gen-barry-mccaffrey/breaking-our-addiction-to_b_245401.html

15 comments:

  1. Morton, you are defending a system that allows first degree murderers to murder again.

    That is insane Morton.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anybody who is addicted to drugs/alcohol can be a serious threat to society given certain circumstances, especially meth addicts!!

    We have to start protecting the public instead of the perpetrators!

    Since our political focus changed some 40 years ago, from protection of society to rehabilitation of the criminal, crime rates have gone skyhigh (although they have come down slightly in the last 2-3 years, coincidentally when the Conservative's "tough on crime" agenda started its implementation).

    Caroline

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous, you are defending a system that allows first degree murderers to murder at will. Any stranger could just pick up a knife from their kitchen drawer and stab you to death in the middle of the street and jails would do absolutely nothing to stop them because jails, along with the entire correctional system we have now, benefit from the victimization of the population.

    The notion that prison time reduces crime is a lie fed to the people in order to keep them ignorant of the massive flaws in the system. To begin with, prison only becomes an issue after a crime has been committed and are utterly incapable of stopping a crime before it occurs.

    In the real world, prisons increase risk factors for crime, drug consumption, gang membership and homelessness. Anyone who knows anything about criminology will tell you this.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Brent - no point in trying to talk sense to silly little anon here. S/he has been posting the same nonsense on every single related post.

    Perhaps if s/he learned to read properly, s/he would realize the problem is not with jailing murderers (and that no one is proposing we stop jailing them). The problem is the huge waste of money it is to jail people convicted of non-violent crime. The article points out how, when so many of the people jailed are addicted to drugs and alcohol, the best way to address their criminal behaviour is to address the drug and alcohol problem via Drug Courts.

    ReplyDelete
  5. What's Taking place i'm new to this, I stumbled upon this I've discovered It positively helpful and it has aided me out loads. I'm hoping to give a contribution & aid other customers like its aided me.
    Good job.

    my weblog: Diet plans for women

    ReplyDelete
  6. I wiѕh thiѕ was on аndгοid.
    .. although if it did I would just make things like thiѕ all еνenіng and not
    get anуthіng ԁone...

    mу ωebsitе ... fast payday loan

    ReplyDelete
  7. You go oveг this а lot bettеr than I eveг cοuld
    - probablу ωhу I dоn't have a thriving blog.

    my web page; personal loans

    ReplyDelete
  8. There's always a new setback right around the corner. Never done huh.

    Also visit my page; fast loans with bad credit

    ReplyDelete