[27] The law properly regards the direct evidence of third parties about the testator's intentions to be inadmissible. There would be much uncertainty and estate litigation if disappointed beneficiaries like Dr. Rondel could challenge a will based on their belief that the testator had different intentions than those manifested in the will.
[28] An apt example is Reishiska v. Cody, 1967 CarswellSask 97 (C.A.). In that case, the testator made a will in which she bequeathed her land to her niece and nephew on the condition that they arrive in Canada within 15 years of her death, or else the land would be transferred absolutely to the defendant. The niece and nephew arrived in Canada, but the defendant sought to introduce evidence that the testator intended that the niece and nephew be landed immigrants or permanent residents, not just visitors. The evidence was inadmissible because it attempted to establish a contrary intention to that determined by giving the words of the will their ordinary and natural meaning. To admit the evidence would have created uncertainty where no uncertainty existed in the words of the will.
[29] An exception to the general rule excluding direct extrinsic evidence of intent in a court of construction arises where there is an "equivocation" in the will. The principle is set out in Feeney, The Canadian Law of Wills: Volume 2 Construction, 2d ed. (Toronto: Butterworths, 1982), at p. 56:
There is an equivocation only where the words of the will, either when read in the light of the whole will or, more usually, when construed in the light of the surrounding circumstances, apply equally well to two or more persons or things. In such a case, extrinsic evidence of the testator's actual intention may be admitted and will usually resolve the equivocation.
[30] In Re Bruce Estate (1998), 24 E.T.R. (2d) 44 (Y.S.C.), the court held that the term "equivocation" is a term of art that has a special meaning in law. The court cautioned against simply equating it with either ambiguity or mere difficulty of interpretation, otherwise there would be no need for rules of interpretation and construction.
[31] The affidavits of Mr. Silverman, Ms. Budi and Dr. Rondel do furnish evidence of some of the surrounding circumstances in this case. Before drafting her Will, Mr. Silverman did not ask the testator about her previous Will, did not review her assets and their location with her, and did not canvass with her the people who she might consider including in the Will. Nor, did she offer any of this information to Mr. Silverman. Taken together, this evidence might give rise to speculation that the testator did not turn her mind to the effect the 2006 Canadian Will would have on the 2002 Spanish Will and the European assets. However, when considered in the light of all the surrounding circumstances including this evidence, there is not the slightest equivocation in the testator's 2006 Canadian Will. The words of the 2006 Canadian Will are clear. As the application judge found, this was not a case about a typographical error, a solicitor's misunderstanding of the testator's instructions or a solicitor's failure to implement the testator's instructions. Rather, the solicitor drafted the testator's Will in accordance with her instructions to deal with the "entire residue of my estate", and she reviewed and approved of the language in the Will before executing it.
[32] The admissible evidence of the surrounding circumstances cannot support the inference that the testator did not intend to revoke the Spanish Will. Mr. Silverman and Dr. Rondel need to rely on the direct evidence of the testator's intent in their affidavits, and urge this court to expand the common law to allow them to do so.
[33] It has been previously suggested that such evidence should be admitted to aid the interpretation of wills. The court's attention was drawn to a 1982 report of the Law Reform Commission of British Columbia that recommended eliminating the exclusionary rules of evidence and admitting all evidence in aid of interpretation that meets the normal evidentiary test of relevance. The recommendation was not accepted.
[34] I prefer the different view taken by the Succession Law Reform Project reporting to the British Columbia Law Institute in a 2006 Report:
The view that has prevailed in the Succession Law Reform Project, however, is that removing all restrictions on admission of extrinsic evidence of intent would allow excessive scope for attempts to secure an interpretation contradicting the actual terms of the will. Fabrications or fantasies of the "he really meant me" or "he always said I would get the house" variety could be advanced much more easily than they can be under the present law. The Testate Succession Subcommittee and Project Committee were not as confident as the Commission had been that litigation over the meaning of wills would not increase if evidence of testamentary intent were made admissible without restriction. They were not prepared to endorse the former Commission's recommendation to abrogate entirely the exclusionary rule regarding extrinsic evidence of intent.
[35] I agree. The evidence of disappointed beneficiaries and other third parties is simply not as probative of testators' intentions as their own clear and unambiguous expressions in the will. Departing from the well-established general exclusionary rule would not lead to a more faithful implementation of testators' true intentions. It would, however, lead to increased litigation. I agree with the observation of Brown J. in Re Kaptyn Estate (2010), 102 O.R. (3d) 1 (S.C.) at para. 36:
The rationale for this principle of admissibility rests in preserving the role of the written will as the primary evidence of the testator's intention and avoiding displacing the written will with an "oral will" gleaned from evidence of the testator's declarations of intent. [Footnotes omitted.]
[36] A testator of sound mind knows her intentions and is able to express them. The very raison d'ętre of a written will, formally executed, is to record the testator's own expression of intentions. The formalities required for the proper execution of the will advance that goal by confirming that the will provides an accurate record of those intentions.
[37] Third-party evidence of a testator's intentions gives rise to both reliability and credibility issues. Credibility is a concern because would-be beneficiaries can, without fear of contradiction by the deceased, exaggerate their relationship and fabricate the promises of requests. Reliability is a concern because testators are not obliged to write their wills to accord with the sincere or mendacious assurances they may have given to those close to them. Until they die, testators may freely revoke or vary the directions they have given for the distribution of their estates. The evidence of third parties, who cannot directly discern the mind of the testator, is logically incapable of directly proving the testator's intent.
[38] In my view, there is no question about the good sense of the common law rule excluding direct extrinsic evidence of a testator's intent
21 comments:
kazx [url=http://stylomontblancsoldes.fr]mont blanc stylo[/url] luhjko http://stylomontblancsoldes.fr wajt [url=http://montblancstylopascher.fr]stylo mont blanc[/url] krasyx http://montblancstylopascher.fr wpvb [url=http://montblancpenscheap.co.uk]cheap mont blanc[/url] bbaqcl http://montblancpenscheap.co.uk svvg [url=http://montblancukstores.co.uk]mont blanc pens[/url] eqfeji http://montblancukstores.co.uk ypol [url=http://montblancpensuksale.co.uk]mont blanc sale[/url] oxexiv http://montblancpensuksale.co.uk ybun [url=http://montblancukshop.co.uk]mont blanc uk[/url] zwkkfm http://montblancukshop.co.uk izwo
hdqyo [url=http://drdrebeatsonlinesale.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] lmazc http://drdrebeatsonlinesale.co.uk lydfy [url=http://beatsdrdresales.co.uk]by dre beats[/url] doids http://beatsdrdresales.co.uk zavwj [url=http://drdrebeatsonlinestores.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] ereyb http://drdrebeatsonlinestores.co.uk ogzgy [url=http://cheapbeatsdrdreonlinesale.com]beats by dre sale[/url] bdoox http://cheapbeatsdrdreonlinesale.com zbmzt [url=http://beatsbydrdreshopping.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] hlbzg http://beatsbydrdreshopping.com sibqb [url=http://beatsbydrdreoutletforsale.com]beats by dre[/url] gklfu http://beatsbydrdreoutletforsale.com digh
avmuj [url=http://drdrebeatscheapsale.co.uk]beats by dre uk[/url] imewj http://drdrebeatscheapsale.co.uk rwkln [url=http://beatsbydrecheapsale.co.uk]beats headphones[/url] qfvgp http://beatsbydrecheapsale.co.uk huhxm [url=http://cheapdrebeats.ca]cheap beats by dre[/url] dmqub http://cheapdrebeats.ca yvopn [url=http://cheapbeatsbydre.ca]cheap beats by dre[/url] gdaro http://cheapbeatsbydre.ca qerho [url=http://beatsheadphonesbydrdre.com]beats headphones[/url] lyami http://beatsheadphonesbydrdre.com llnnl [url=http://beatsbydreoutletshops.com]beats outlet[/url] hhwxv http://beatsbydreoutletshops.com aqfa
cabta [url=http://drdrebeatsonlinesale.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] rjjeh http://drdrebeatsonlinesale.co.uk bbsrf [url=http://beatsdrdresales.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] nwqla http://beatsdrdresales.co.uk bahwk [url=http://drdrebeatsonlinestores.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] rxsju http://drdrebeatsonlinestores.co.uk bmfsx [url=http://cheapbeatsdrdreonlinesale.com]beats by dre[/url] vkmrx http://cheapbeatsdrdreonlinesale.com aaigt [url=http://beatsbydrdreshopping.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] jowzr http://beatsbydrdreshopping.com vremf [url=http://beatsbydrdreoutletforsale.com]beats by dre[/url] bfnld http://beatsbydrdreoutletforsale.com vjsh
qvwsm [url=http://newestredsoleshoes.com]cheap christian louboutin[/url] mxbqyv http://newestredsoleshoes.com oepjz [url=http://redbottomsoutletsale.com]red bottoms[/url] pqprdu http://redbottomsoutletsale.com dlktt [url=http://cheaplouboutinoutletforwomen.com]christian louboutin outlet[/url] swzos http://cheaplouboutinoutletforwomen.com mjebg [url=http://newchristianlouboutinssale.com]christian louboutin sale[/url] uqvgs http://newchristianlouboutinssale.com obhzx ozlua [url=http://bestchristianlouboutinstore.com]christian louboutin[/url] blfuq http://bestchristianlouboutinstore.com uzezv [url=http://louboutinonlinestores.com]christian louboutin sale[/url] pjflq http://louboutinonlinestores.com eozll
ftwwi [url=http://www.salelouisvuitton-no1.com]louis vuitton handbags[/url] khitly http://www.salelouisvuitton-no1.com kettt [url=http://www.get-louisvuittonoutlet.com]cheap louis vuitton[/url] gtppgv http://www.get-louisvuittonoutlet.com kueee [url=http://www.pick-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] yloexn http://www.pick-louisvuittonoutlet.com kuoc [url=http://www.foxlouisvuitton.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] kacwar http://www.foxlouisvuitton.com wqpsd [url=http://www.lo-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] wanthb http://www.lo-louisvuittonoutlet.com xxzuf [url=http://www.locheaplouisvuitton.com]louis vuitton handbags[/url] gazitz http://www.locheaplouisvuitton.com gocp
xesdn [url=http://www.pickcelinehandbags.com]celine handbags[/url] mlkpgi http://www.pickcelinehandbags.com piqoe [url=http://www.savecelinehandbags.com]canada handbags[/url] tgiawg http://www.savecelinehandbags.com nvqxo [url=http://www.savecelinebags.com]celine bag[/url] xtorlu http://www.savecelinebags.com relg [url=http://www.goodcelinebags.com]celine handbags[/url] oqovnr http://www.goodcelinebags.com jtjxo [url=http://www.goodcelinehandbags.com]celine bag[/url] jwslww http://www.goodcelinehandbags.com nwgoy [url=http://www.onlinecelinebags.com]celine bag online[/url] qtfrzn http://www.onlinecelinebags.com aytx
gvrog [url=http://www.foxbeatsbydre.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] jdgcw http://www.foxbeatsbydre.co.uk jcavj [url=http://www.add-beatsbydre.co.uk]beats by dre[/url] chtio http://www.add-beatsbydre.co.uk jmsbu [url=http://www.beatsshop2013.com]dr dre beats[/url] nivgl http://www.beatsshop2013.com apikb [url=http://www.onlinecheapbeatsbydre.com]dre beats[/url] qxndx http://www.onlinecheapbeatsbydre.com rzewf [url=http://www.justdrdrebeatssale.com]beats by dre[/url] hqthd http://www.justdrdrebeatssale.com qvjzi [url=http://www.vip-beatsbydresale.com]dr dre beats[/url] ajeju http://www.vip-beatsbydresale.com xkui
duguy [url=http://www.add-celinehandbags.co.uk]celine handbags[/url] mjwjfl http://www.add-celinehandbags.co.uk kypkp [url=http://www.add-celinebags.co.uk]cheap celine bag[/url] cvuhga http://www.add-celinebags.co.uk jlieu [url=http://www.getcelinebags.co.uk]celine handbags[/url] uqyklu http://www.getcelinebags.co.uk gypt [url=http://www.pay-celinebags.co.uk]celine handbags[/url] vhwqik http://www.pay-celinebags.co.uk fwcsi [url=http://www.pay-celinehandbags.co.uk]celine handbags[/url] iaqfsy http://www.pay-celinehandbags.co.uk buysn [url=http://www.online-celinebags.co.uk]celine bags[/url] xejhpz http://www.online-celinebags.co.uk fdtk
bsh [url=http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com]Celine Bags[/url] rmz http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com bpz [url=http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com]Celine Bags[/url] vdp http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com rye [url=http://www.celinebagxiao.com]Celine Handbags[/url] lfd http://www.celinebagxiao.com gda [url=http://www.celinehandbagswe.com]Celine Bags[/url] tmm http://www.celinehandbagswe.com xxg [url=http://www.drdrebeatsname.com]Cheap Beats By Dre[/url] mbz http://www.drdrebeatsname.com qyi
beats by dre whtnggbv casque beats by dre pas cher pgbeaoxh casque beats by dre jopfeifm casque docteur dre zpkvpmar casque monster beats pas cher bbolfnrx casque monster beats opwyaiyc ecouteur beats xhhrdjsk monster beats pas cher fbigyejy monster beats upsfzbqy
beats by dr dre tegkjrmg beats by dre jidcbrpn beats dr dre nkgyjfqb beats for sale fxxgemoo beats headphones qnxdqcex cheap monster beats mppvluez dr dre beats fbhtnuim dr dre headphones edacaohm monster beats by dre lnmtplit monster beats headphones owleviug monster beats zjhlpqgm monster headphones kjdgrbyh
coach outlet rhadvkur coach usa fiddoqqh coach factory outlet imxhuppm coach factory zkhmqrsj
mcm [url=http://www.beatsbydrename.com]Cheap Beats By Dre[/url] awn http://www.beatsbydrename.com myp [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrelo.com]Beats By Dre[/url] vji http://www.cheapbeatsbydrelo.com rth [url=http://www.drdrebeatswe.com]Beats By Dre[/url] mnm http://www.drdrebeatswe.com msl [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrewe.com]Cheap Beats By Dre[/url] vth http://www.cheapbeatsbydrewe.com dnr [url=http://www.beatsbydrewe.com]Dr Dre Beats[/url] kqr http://www.beatsbydrewe.com dpt [url=http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com]Celine Bag[/url] gfq http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com ift [url=http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com]Celine Handbags[/url] hta http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com nok
cheap ugg boots sale olcgkiri cheap ugg boots uk wpclltfe cheap ugg boots bvqchwiz cheap uggs arzwspqf ugg boots sale uk qmzbdqth ugg boots sale pgqqghbi ugg boots uk agnirbhz ugg boots yzzshpxi ugg sale qujllnjx
beats by dr dre dohpxgmh beats by dre vqmcuyhw beats dr dre jrrlxdoh beats for sale iwtgzsab beats headphones otzgsfpz cheap monster beats mmunysyx dr dre beats zgfdjvmm dr dre headphones hxetprlg monster beats by dre lmvcgeqh monster beats headphones aufaqzzm monster beats beexsycj monster headphones hfyuecij
cdhqy [url=http://www.mulberrybagswe.co.uk]mulberry outlet[/url] jaqlw http://www.mulberrybagswe.co.uk qhkpv [url=http://www.mulberryoutletwe.co.uk]mulberry sale[/url] hjidg http://www.mulberryoutletwe.co.uk eftfl [url=http://www.im-mulberrybags.co.uk]mulberry handbags[/url] qimxw http://www.im-mulberrybags.co.uk wvxpq [url=http://www.im-mulberryoutlet.co.uk]mulberry sale[/url] aciqv http://www.im-mulberryoutlet.co.uk nexmm [url=http://www.pay-mulberrybags.co.uk]mulberry handbags[/url] kmhik http://www.pay-mulberrybags.co.uk xpfz [url=http://www.online-mulberry.co.uk]mulberry outlet[/url] ivhnx http://www.online-mulberry.co.uk alxmw
iuauo [url=http://www.cheaper-montblancpens.com]Mont Blanc Pens[/url] wsfoza http://www.cheaper-montblancpens.com cmiyf [url=http://www.montblancpensincheap.com]Mont Blanc Pens[/url] qbnlmv http://www.montblancpensincheap.com vzfdy [url=http://www.montblanconlines.com]Mont Blanc Pens[/url] bfgsoh http://www.montblanconlines.com kgkt [url=http://www.cheapmontblancpens.co.uk]Mont Blanc[/url] lqouxe http://www.cheapmontblancpens.co.uk olcme [url=http://www.salemontblancpens.co.uk]Mont Blanc Pens[/url] gyhfyv http://www.salemontblancpens.co.uk gndlf [url=http://www.montblanconlines.co.uk]Mont Blanc yhsjtb http://www.montblanconlines.co.uk ainy
zom [url=http://www.hollisteroutletnamee.com]Hollister Outlet[/url] iak http://www.hollisteroutletnamee.com rrx [url=http://www.hollisterjeansname.com]Hollister Jeans[/url] flo http://www.hollisterjeansname.com jzm [url=http://www.hollisteroutletname.com]Hollister Jeans[/url] ljz http://www.hollisteroutletname.com tep [url=http://www.hollisterjeanswe.com]Hollister Jeans[/url] ohy http://www.hollisterjeanswe.com swj [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrename.com]Hollister Outlet[/url] yig http://www.cheapbeatsbydrename.com tjm [url=http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com]Celine Handbags[/url] zaq http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com zvh [url=http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com]Celine Bag[/url] hyw http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com ipp
ord [url=http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com]Celine Handbags[/url] zwr http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com kwq [url=http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com]Celine Bags[/url] dsu http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com scj [url=http://www.celinebagxiao.com]Celine Handbags[/url] xso http://www.celinebagxiao.com gdi [url=http://www.celinehandbagswe.com]Celine Bag[/url] ild http://www.celinehandbagswe.com owc [url=http://www.drdrebeatsname.com]Dr Dre Beats[/url] gbs http://www.drdrebeatsname.com gwb [url=http://www.hollisteroutletnamee.com]Hollister Clothing[/url] obn http://www.hollisteroutletnamee.com xwe [url=http://www.hollisterjeansname.com]Hollister Outlet[/url] tnk http://www.hollisterjeansname.com yxf
rea [url=http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com]Celine Bag[/url] bwn http://www.celineluggagetotediscount.com fqd [url=http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com]Celine Bags[/url] ipf http://www.celinehandbagsdiscount.com yhb [url=http://www.celinebagxiao.com]Celine Handbags[/url] vhn http://www.celinebagxiao.com sgo [url=http://www.celinehandbagswe.com]Celine Bags[/url] whq http://www.celinehandbagswe.com ilp [url=http://www.drdrebeatsname.com]Dr Dre Beats[/url] uwf http://www.drdrebeatsname.com vyo
Post a Comment