Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Farmers vote to maintain wheat board's monopoly

The Board amounts to a Union for farmers -- dismantling the Board in the face of this vote is suggestive of what may be the future of Federally regulated Unions?


WINNIPEG—Prairie farmers have voted in favour of the Canadian Wheat Board's monopoly over wheat and barley sales.

Just over 60 per cent of wheat growers and 51 per cent of barley growers voted in favour of maintaining the board's monopoly. Some 55 per cent of wheat growers and 47 per cent of barley growers voted in the plebiscite.

The board conducted a plebiscite after federal Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz refused to hold one as required under the Canadian Wheat Board Act.

Ritz has said he will change the law and eliminate the monopoly, although the board would still exist.

"In an open market, every farmer will have the ability to choose how to market their grain, whether it’s individually or through a voluntary pooling entity," he said in emailed comments Friday before he knew the plebiscite result.

"Let me repeat — regardless of the plebiscite results — at the end of the day, every farmer will have the right to choose how they market their grain."

Ritz has the support of provincial governments in British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan.

The Winnipeg-based wheat board has the support of the Manitoba government, which believes farmers have the legal right to decide the marketing agency's future.

Legislation creating the board dates back to 1935. The monopoly over wheat came into effect in 1943. Barley and oats were added a few years later.

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

1. Why does it only apply to western farmers?

2. It was a plebiscite. It is non-binding and farmers knew it going in. This is nothing more than a glorified poll.

Only about half the farmers bothered to respond. Why? I suspect they were not going to waste their time engaging in this farce.

It seems to me that enrollment in the wheat board should be voluntary.

Holly Stick said...

Why does it apply to western farmers? Maybe because western farmers grow roughly 96-98% of the wheat in Canada?

http://www.fas.usda.gov/remote/canada/can_wha.htm

http://www.spectrumcommodities.com/education/commodity/statistics/wheat.html

Anonymous said...

Holly; There are some big farms in Ontario.

My sense is the wheat board is a relic of the Liberal party of Canada telling western farmers what is in their best interest.

Again fully half of them ignored the plebiscite entirely. They clearly had little respect for the vote and process. No?

The Rat said...

I can point out the mendacity in comparing the wheat board to union, I can state that it is morally wrong to deprive a farmer of the benefit of his work, his choice in what to do with it. I can point out that the lack of fairness in forcing only farmers in Western Canada to sell to the wheat board, or I could mention that jail time for selling wheat outside the board is draconian. But why? Face it boys and girls, the wheat board is dead so you may as well lie back, think of England, and get it over with.

Holly Stick said...

Anonymous. learn some history:

"...Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, farmers actively lobbied for a government agency to control the marketing of wheat..."

http://www.rhondaparkinson.com/canadian-wheat-board.htm

The Rat: you are not welcome in Alberta, your arguments mean nothing, and your final analogy is repulsive.

The Rat said...

Well, Holly, if you're a Liberal you'd know about being "unwelcome" in Alberta. Also, I am pleased as punch you picked up on that offensiveness, it was most definitely deliberate. Enjoy!

Anonymous said...

Holly. In the 1920's women in many parts of Canada couldn't vote.

Things can and do change.

Annie said...

It was R.B. Bennet,way back then, that started the Wheat Board

Holly Stick said...

The Repellant Rat, I am a lifelong Albertan, not a Liberal and not stupid or vicious enough to be a rightwinger.

Ignorant Anonymous, most women in Canada got the vote before 1920:

http://www.parl.gc.ca/ParlInfo/Compilations/ProvinceTerritory/ProvincialWomenRightToVote.aspx

Anon is no doubt also too ignorant to know that R.B. Bennett was a Conservative.

Annie said...

And to all you ignoramus's, R.B. Bennett also started the CBC

Anonymous said...

Remember once upon a time when Conservatives worked to build up the country, rather than tear it apart? Now all we're left with is neo-liberal reformist radicals that have stolen the Conservative name.

Their legislation is always either some ultimately meaningless issue designed to split the country, lip service to their more extreme base so they don't go forming their own party, or selling out to foreign financial interests. All for personal power and blind neo-liberal ideology.

Anonymous said...

This one has hit a nerve.

Holly should learn to read before calling others ignorant. While it is true that women (in general) did earn the vote in Canada prior to the 1920's not all could. In provincial elections Quebec women couldn't vote until 1940.

RB Bennett was PM 80 years ago. The country has changed a tad.

Anonymous said...

Hey Rat, forget what Holly says. You are welcome in Alberta anytime.

Anonymous said...

Thеѕe are аlso avaіlаble with PTΟ Dеlay featuге which automatiсallу open tаnκ inteгnal valve foг 5 secоnds ρгior tο еngaging РΤO
аllowing pump and pгоduсt lines to сhargе preѵіeωing intегval valνe slug.
Alѕо, by hаѵing а radio inteгnship in yοur resume, thеrе is a
betteг chance foг уou tо become a DJ ωhеn you applу for a jоb
in any radіо station іn the nаtion.
Additіоnаlly, some neω attrіbutеs make it even еasier to
mаκe гadio buttons do exасtly
what you want them to dο.

Αlso visit mу homepage: http://www.ev-dragon.com/wiki/index.php?title=Utilisateur:BennyI88

Anonymous said...

5. Once the number of back links will increase,
web traffic flow will enhance. The more doors you have the more chances of people finding it.
While you’re at it, remove all or fix 404 errors. Organic SEO uses
valid and safe techniques to rank your site for its keyword.

There are so many good blogs out there, and if you're one of those writers, you definitely know how important it is that your site gets heard through all of the noise. Domain Authority is influenced by:. Having realized that it is practically not possible to combat with SEO Next in terms of services and offerings at this point of time, rivals have started thinking of an easier alternative of being successful in their mission. The title is supposed to explain the article, and the title is what your readers see when they search for content. Over the years, web promotion has made a mark in the industry and has helped numerous entrepreneurs to build large business return through web. Use SEM experts to recognize duplicate content as part of your website, and act immediately to have it settled. He has also mentioned each and every seo service. Let us assume that at this point you have 6 keywords. An SEO strategy should combine a number of elements that work together to get results for you. This was the beginning of the thought process for my new business. It has been designed especially for business purposes and it holds biggest importance for your B2B online marketing strategy. Many organizations try to secure you into extremely lengthy agreements to assurance transaction even if they aren't able to provide outcomes.

When a person enters a keyword into the search box
of a particular search engine such as Google, there will be scores
of results showing out which are a result of a search engine algorithm devised by
that particular search engine. What is the magic formula.
============ More at: Comment "Smartly" & Increase
Page Views: Writing Essentials 8.

My webpage http://www.choni.es/index.php?do=/profile-2230/info

Anonymous said...

Thаnk you a lot foг sharing this
with all folκs you rеallу know what you are sрeаking about!
Boоkmaгκеd. Kindly also talk
over with my web site =). We may hаve a hyperlіnκ trade contract betwееn us

Look at my blog; http://wiwt.com/user/gearrun2

Anonymous said...

It's genuinely very complicated in this active life to listen news on Television, therefore I only use web for that reason, and take the latest information.

My web blog :: radio sender
Also see my page: online radio

Anonymous said...

With ԁozenѕ of гаdіο aρpѕ for i -
Phone available in i - Τunes, there is аn аpp for eѵery cаtеgorу of music
lover to lοvе. Another thing you'll need is some strength to endure, because there's
a gooԁ chance you'll be your own producer for the show or perhaps the best producer the show has. Proffering multifarious benefits to the advertisers, it is a quintessential resort for companies big or small.

My site - bildungsstreik.net

Anonymous said...

However, the number of apps is steadily rising, and if Nokia
continues to put out quality phones like the Lumia 900, we may see developers take
more notice and the number of apps will rise
accordingly. Stored energy printers. Hometown Retired households
are comprised of retirees, two-thirds of whom
are over 65; nonetheless, don't assume that these people don't
do much more than hang around the house and watch
TV all day. So, in conclusion, removing the headphones from
your MP3 player is not bad, provided you don't yank too hard on the cord. Many consumers worry about their security when making purchases over the internet. Those pain killers and medications hide the problem without dealing with the true cause. They will check into a purpose built sports complex 8 miles from the venue of their first match in Rustenburg. FIFA has stated that a player named as a goalkeeper can only play in goal and that this rule will be enforced. *Composite fillings. There is a rarely discussed addiction that can be as enslaving as drugs and as devastating to self-respect, self-confidence and healthy functioning as alcoholism.

my page A Guide To Quick Plans In crysis | fiestabrochure.com

Anonymous said...

Everyone loves it when folks come together and share thoughts.
Great website, stick with it!

My site; myvideo downloader

Anonymous said...

Have you ever considered about adding a little
bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is important
and all. Nevertheless just imagine if you added
some great pictures or video clips to give your posts more, "pop"!
Your content is excellent but with pics and clips, this website could certainly be
one of the best in its niche. Excellent blog!

My site http://ferkaudahrexu.webs.com/apps/blog/show/21848246-the-prime-minister-the-cabinet-and-parliament-is-only-a-facade-to-conceal-the-true-power-of-britain-

Anonymous said...

Hold down an app for a second, and start turning off all the apps that
you aren't using by pressing the "minus" button. Their producers imagine this can make the user a lot more mindful in the should change the batteries, lessening the prospect of the discover program failing through ability loss. Aside from these types of power packs, you can even choose the 8-cell and also 12-cell electric battery.

My weblog; http://social.bbabssfv.com/

Anonymous said...

Үou сan alsο buy bundle ԁeals, which most
гadio statіons offer, to ԁeсrease the oνerall аd cost.
(Сhесk out the article: Whаt's Really Out There in the Night Sky to see how some celestial objects appear at different EM frequencies. Even if you have a good two way radio, it isn't baԁ to
hаvе some kіnԁ of rеcеiνe onlу rаdio to
get infοrmatiοn οn.

Stοp bу my web page :: youtube downloader online

Anonymous said...

Please supplement charge before use when the battery has been kept for a long time.
Their producers imagine this can make the user a lot more mindful in
the should change the batteries, lessening the prospect of the discover
program failing through ability loss. Pingbatterys battery administration program (BMS) might have the
line of Light emitting diodes visible.

Also visit my webpage online radio

Anonymous said...

I realize that there is not a ton of variety in this list,
since Rogue and i - Net - Hack are essentially the same and Sorcerer #1 and #2 are more overtly the same.

Resident Evil 2 is the undisputed king daddy in the world of early survival horror.
Each child is given 30 seconds to race to the pile and make as many
matches as possible before time runs out.

Feel free to surf to my blog post; youtube downloader online

Anonymous said...

With the You - Tube Mobile Application you can also find videos with
the easy to use search tool and record and play DVD quality videos direct on your phone.
Yes, the present administrators of the odyssey streaming radio LLC have worked hard to launch excellent radio
entertainment programs. Not only for the business users but this
dedicated seedbox is very useful for even personal users.



Feel free to surf to my weblog ... just click the up coming document