The fact is Canada does not make economic sense -- looking at economics only Canada would be far better folded into the North American market. If we want a nation, as opposed to a loose federation of local places, we need to have proper land links. Look at Alaska -- that State has proper highways.
Officials say if road is built, it must be for national, not economic, reasons
CBC News
A study obtained by CBC News shows the cost of a road from Manitoba to Nunavut would likely far outweigh its economic benefits.
However, Canada was built by rail, road and waterways, and people who are pushing for a land link between Nunavut and the South believe the country still has one major piece of nation-building left.
"Nunavut is joined to the rest of Canada by only the thinnest of threads," said Nunavut Premier Eva Aariak.
Aariak told a Toronto audience last year that Nunavut clings to confederation without a single ground link to the South.
For years, Nunavut and Manitoba have talked about an all-weather road connecting the two regions.
A recently released business case study shows a road from Rankin Inlet, Nunavut, to Sundance, Man., would cost $1.2 billion. The study also shows the 1,100-kilometre road would generate less than half that amount in benefits.
"This is a tough sell, it's a tough sell on the economics, and it's a tough sell just because of the magnitude of it," said Shawn Maley, a spokesperson for the Nunavut government.
Would be interesting to see excerpts from this economic study, what they counted in. But I agree, many great projects are done without hoping to recover costs. Not all benefits can be truly counted!
ReplyDelete