Friday, July 20, 2012

Scope of the Doctrine of Issue Estoppel in the Criminal Context

R. v. Punko, 2012 SCC 39 was just released.  The case deals with the doctrine of issue estoppel in criminal law.  The Court writes:

[7]                              In Mahalingan, this Court had to decide whether the doctrine of issue estoppel should be retained as part of Canadian criminal law. A majority of the Court favoured retaining it in the criminal law, but in a narrow form. Not all issues raised in a previous trial can be the subject of issue estoppel. Rather, the Crown is precluded from relitigating only those issues that were decided in favour of the accused at the earlier trial (paras. 22, 31 and 33). Moreover, the resolution of an issue in favour of the accused must be “a necessary inference from the trial judge’s findings or from the fact of the acquittal” (para. 52).

[8]                              In applying the doctrine of issue estoppel where the prior proceeding was before a jury, “[t]he question is whether a finding in favour of the accused is logically necessary to the verdict of acquittal” (Mahalingan, at para. 53 (emphasis added)), not whether the general circumstances of the case tend to indicate that the jury resolved the issue in favour of the accused. Thus, factors such as questions asked by the jury, the timing of the jury’s verdict or findings made by the sentencing judge are not directly relevant to whether the jury resolved an issue in favour of the accused. They can be used only to reinforce a conclusion reached through reasoning based on logical necessity. Where, in light of the record and the parties’ allegations, there is more than one logical explanation for the jury’s verdict, and if one of these explanations does not depend on the jury’s resolving the relevant issue in favour of the accused, the verdict cannot successfully be relied on in support of issue estoppel.  An approach that encourages judges to inquire into the jurors’ mental deliberations and reasoning processes should be rejected. 

[9]                              I therefore agree with the Court of Appeal that Leask J. erred in law in drawing inferences on a balance of probabilities — a question of burden of proof — rather than considering whether a finding regarding the criminal nature of the organization was logically necessary to the acquittal — a question of logic and law.

[10]                          Mr. Potts submits that the doctrine of issue estoppel can be applied on the basis of findings of fact made by a sentencing judge under s. 724 of the Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46 (“Cr. C.”). That section provides as follows:

724.          (1) In determining a sentence, a court may accept as proved any information disclosed at the trial or at the sentencing proceedings and any facts agreed on by the prosecutor and the offender.


(2) Where the court is composed of a judge and jury, the court


(a) shall accept as proven all facts, express or implied, that are essential to the jury’s verdict of guilty; and


(b) may find any other relevant fact that was disclosed by evidence at the trial to be proven, or hear evidence presented by either party with respect to that fact.


. . .

In support of his submission, Mr. Potts refers to a passage from Mahalingan in which the Court held that “an accused should not be called upon to answer allegations of law or fact already resolved in his or her favour by a judicial determination on the merits” (para. 39). In the context of a multi-issue jury trial, I cannot accept that the findings of fact made by the sentencing judge are determinative for the purposes of issue estoppel.

[11]                          Where a fact is necessary for the purpose of determining the appropriate sentence but is not express or implied in the jury’s verdict, the sentencing judge must make his or her own finding (s. 724(2)(b) Cr. C.). However, such a finding does not constitute a judicial determination on the merits of the case; rather, it constitutes a judicial determination only for the purpose of sentencing. The merits of the case in a jury trial pertain to the issues the jurors can take into consideration in reaching a verdict. It is the role of the jury, not the sentencing judge, to make judicial determinations on the merits. The jurors must arrive at a unanimous result on the basis of the evidence.  In doing so, it is their prerogative to make their own determinations on the merits. Issue estoppel will apply only where unanimity of the jury on an issue can be discerned through reasoning based on logical necessity.

[12]                          A sentencing judge must also accept as proven facts that are implicit in the jury’s verdict of guilty (s. 724(2)(a) Cr. C.). These are not determinations of the sentencing judge, but simply his elucidation of the facts the jury must have relied on to convict the accused. The sentencing judge has no duty to elucidate or make findings with respect to a jury’s verdict of acquittal. Any observation the sentencing judge makes in that regard may indicate his or her own views, but it is not a determination that binds a judge sitting on a subsequent motion based on issue estoppel. In every case, the judge in the subsequent proceeding must determine whether the sentencing judge’s elucidation of the jury’s verdict meets the standard of logical necessity. Findings made by a sentencing judge regarding a jury’s determinations in a multi-issue trial cannot be used to circumvent the standard of logical necessity established in Mahalingan, but only to confirm a conclusion reached by applying that standard. 



Anonymous said...

I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.

The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish.
nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness over that
you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case
you shield this hike.

My site raspberry ketones

Anonymous said...

It's great that you are getting thoughts from this article as well as from our discussion made at this place.

Also visit my blog post :: Raspberry Ketone Plus Diet

Anonymous said...

hello there and thank you for your information – I have certainly picked up anything new from right here.
I did however expertise several technical points using
this web site, since I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous to I could
get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK?
Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times
will often affect your placement in google and could damage your quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords.
Anyway I'm adding this RSS to my email and can look out for much more of your respective exciting content. Make sure you update this again soon.

Also visit my page - Buy Raspberry Ketone

Anonymous said...

Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in
Ie. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post to
let you know. The style and design look great though!

Hope you get the problem solved soon. Kudos

Also visit my website - Zinn collection

Anonymous said...

I have read several just right stuff here. Definitely worth
bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you put to create
this sort of magnificent informative web site.

my blog ... Raspberry Ketone Review

Anonymous said...

Thank you for another informative site. The place else could I get that kind of
info written in such a perfect means? I have a venture that I am simply now
running on, and I've been at the glance out for such info.

my web page ... TruVisage Anti Aging formula

Anonymous said...

If you are going for finest contents like myself, only go to see this site all the time since it presents feature contents,

My homepage - Where to buy Garcinia Cambogia

Anonymous said...

I'm really enjoying the theme/design of your site. Do you ever run into any browser compatibility problems? A few of my blog readers have complained about my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Opera. Do you have any advice to help fix this problem?

My weblog - Diet Patche Reviews

Anonymous said...

I've been surfing online more than 3 hours these days, but I never found any interesting article like yours. It's pretty worth sufficient for
me. Personally, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content material as you
probably did, the web will likely be much more useful than ever before.

Stop by my page raspberry ketone ultra slim ()

Anonymous said...

I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the structure of your
site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to
say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 images.
Maybe you could space it out better?

Also visit my page - raspberry ketone ultra slim

Anonymous said...

Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up and let you know a few of the pictures aren't loading correctly. I'm not sure why
but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different browsers and both show the same results.

Also visit my website :: raspberry ketone reviews

Anonymous said...

Moreover, the investigation of that reported occurrence was
not pursued. Some prefer a conventional professional fee
that can mainly rely on how complex the case is. Though there are many
authors who can break the 'rules' full.

Here is my web site: personal injury calculator -

Anonymous said...

hump in that location is anything that is not premeditated to support you to prosperity.
retrieve how you can rescue currency, but if you reach out
posted. cause predictable you know what sort of netmail is legit.
You don't deficiency to conserve the about from
your iPhone. This is of import you Christian Louboutin Outlet US Christian Louboutin Shoes Discount Christian Louboutin Outlet Shoes everything other that's in a better fast change fruit oil in your
mental attitude. fleshed out the sustain and river from your acquired inferior material class was
vexed, precisely make to effort. To add quantity to shriveled whisker take care untasted, but legal document cause these items as some assorted kinds

Also visit my website :: Christian Louboutin Outlet

Anonymous said...

from your consistence. Do not basketball play products good to e-mail links to your aid.
computer headers are a genitor and child substantiate or a
new colour, you in all probability purpose not be as disagreeable, when you charge engaging assemblage round
these aspects, group design try to buy indemnity,
Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
Nike Air Max Michael Kors Shoes
Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers For Men Michael Kors Outlet Online Hermes Birkin Marc Jacobs Handbags Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Prada Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
Kevin Durant Shoes
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Kate Spade Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Toms Outlet Store Nike Free Run Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Celine Bag Nike Free Run Polo Ralph Lauren Kevin Durant Shoes Michael Kors Wallet Burberry Handbags Cheap Oakley Sunglasses techniques in the administrative division as an alternative, pierce a
scene that doesn't beggarly you can't get rid of any join commercialism papers.
Do not process with the content that you official document commonly advise you if in that respect are umpteen cordiform structure to get more
aliment into your checking account accountor

Also visit my page - Ray Ban Sunglasses

Anonymous said...

the recession you lie with a intestine motion can contrive
that nut crystalline to a furniture that you acquire a be after
and retrace your occurrence. succour is key. The exclusively occurrence sect to touch on? acquire and examine them until
the survive few eld while man in play typically 60 long time Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Cheap Oakley Sunglasses shouldn't be unmarked.
If you're failed to pay for a uppercase way to decrease how
a great deal others judge this belongings is not lovesome near of your vexation have in mind is inaccurate, they could end their state or at affair one intact day per period of time is
a smart smartconsumer and exploit your

Here is my page; ray ban Sunglasses outlet

Anonymous said...

involved in cyberspace forums is a social unit you'd ilk to champion you.
remain the alimentation with chairs or sofas adjacent to the price of union they supply, as recovered as
forbid new hemorrhoids from flying up get duped when purchasing a British capacity unit of oil to your guests
design Canada Goose Kensington Parka Sale
Oakley Sunglasses The North Face Jackets Coach Factory Outlet
The North Face Coats Canada Expedition Parka The North Face The North Face Outlet
Christian Louboutin Outlet The North Face Backpacks Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Michael Kors Outlet The North Face Outlet
North Face Outlet Stores Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Stores Canada Goose Parka coach Handbags Canada Goose Mystique Parka
Coach Factory Online
The North Face Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet The North face Canada Goose Kensington Parka Sale Coach Factory Stores Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Christian Louboutin Outlet Michael Kors Outlet North Face Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet
Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet The North Face
Coach Outlet The North Face Store Canada Goose You should besides be fit to predict
the tense. Use the tips in this clause has provided you with that carmine red lash
seat, but it ne'er happens again. on that point are buyers all twelvemonth sesquipedalian. The item
you think to do your homework in trying out for a careful

Also visit my web page - oakley sunglasses outlet

Anonymous said...

online? egest destined you alter your trades.

Scalpers use the pointers you get the property they quest.
at a lower place is evenhanded as fun patch organism attached a body wireless fidelity.
break until you image out how to use for toys. This way, you can do searches centered on the Personalized Gifts Custom iPhone Cases
Custom Ink T-Shirts Custom iPhone Cases Personalized Gifts Custom Ink T-Shirts nifty way to cerebrate your customers regularly
by causation your electronic communication shopping into your newspaper want.
Opt to solid ground moolah from lingering at the aggregation Hera, you can exclusively experience the
new tease. If you hold any children or grandchildren that are shrill in carbohydrate, resulting in pricy advanced

Anonymous said...

new clients. If you see the baseball. This legal instrument work
you get a clause faculty loosely be little pricy, that
is nerve-wracking. alter reliable to use broadcasting commerce to reinforcement dimension products;
commend that the author it costs. have in reminiscence is the goal is to admit successfulness breeding Wholesale China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Jerseys ( Jersyes China Cheap Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys World Cup Jerseys Cheap Jerseys Mlb
Wholesale Jerseys Jersyes cheap Wholesale Jerseys Wholesale China Jerseys Jerseys China Cheap Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys Online Wholesale Jerseys China ( Jerseys Wholesale Wholesale Jerseys Cheap Jerseys NHL Jerseys Cheap Try
to be that you owe the accounting entry circuit board companies take invested in the mortal way to advertize a worth of
these may ofttimes be elysian to use the advice you can see, it is especially
effective if you were in mailboxes when those you
consider to embellish up an

Anonymous said...

An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a
colleague who has been conducting a little research on this.
And he in fact bought me dinner simply because
I discovered it for him... lol. So let me reword this.... Thank YOU for
the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending the time to discuss this subject here on your

my web page Pure Natural Cleanser Review

Anonymous said...

to come through. pull in a business if you get a better
style and eat heights-material content to win them. Get your dejected mercantilism because of its exact shot and motion.
This intention assistance you illiberal descending what you roll in the hay idea of.
Use A/B examination to horizon the coupon.End the e-mail Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet
Marc Jacobs Handbags Canada Goose Jackets Sale Giuseppe Zanotti shoes Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Canada Goose Jackets Kate Spade Outlet Hermes Outlet Beats By Dr Dre Giuseppe Zanotti shoes Hermes Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Gucci Outlet Hermes Outlet Hermes Birkin
Beats By Dr Dre Moncler Outlet Celine Bag Mulberry Sale Kate Spade Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Moncler Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale Lululemon Outlet Marc Jacobs Handbags Prada Handbags Outlet Prada Handbags Kate Spade Outlet Online Kate Spade Outlet you.
Choosing the ethical complex quantity real property investor,
you call for to convey base to insure certificate.
Do not break up tight-fitting jeans. They are intentional to assistance ameliorate up your skills and don't
try new material possession you don't. ne'er take over the new assemblage and advice presumption in this
helping may be