Friday, August 24, 2012

No inquiry of juror absent misconduct during trial

R v Poon, 2012 SKCA 76 deals with an unusual situation. After the start of trial information came to the court in a jury trial that a juror had been the victim of a crime similar to that which was it issue at trial. There was no suggestion the juror had done anything improper during the trial or had misled the court before becoming a juror. The trial judge declined to make special inquiry of the juror and the Court of Appeal agreed:



[13] After adjourning the matter overnight, Malone J. gave thoughtful reasons why he was not prepared to conduct any further inquiries of either the caller or the juror (see: Transcript, pp. 633-36). Malone J. began his reasons by recounting these factors: (i) he had already asked, during jury selection, whether any of the prospective jurors had been a victim of sexual assault and, if so, whether he or she could nonetheless act impartially; (ii) the jurors had sworn an oath saying that they would deliver a true verdict; and (iii) during his opening instructions he had explained a series of fundamental principles, including the presumption of innocence and the Crown's obligation to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. He then concluded his reasons with the following:

This is not a situation where there are allegations of misconduct by a juror during a trial or during deliberations. The situation here is that a person has advised the Local Registrar that because of a past history a juror may not be impartial. However, just because a person has been selected to act as a juror it doesn't give the court or anyone else the licence to ask personal and intimate questions, no matter how diplomatically they are phrased, about their past life. I refer to the safeguards in place to ensure that a juror acts impartially, and I'm not prepared to, in effect, ignore these safeguards on the basis of unsubstantiated allegations. I must assume that the juror in question does not hold a bias with respect to the accused or the Crown, that the juror will be true to the oath taken, and the juror will follow the instructions I have referred to when the jurors retire to consider their verdicts.... [Transcript, p. 635; emphasis added.]

Malone J. then imposed a publication ban with respect to any information that would identify either the caller or the affected juror, and sealed the envelope containing the Local Registrar's memorandum and notes of the call. With that, the trial resumed.



[14] On appeal, Dr. Poon asks this Court to quash his client's convictions on the basis of a miscarriage of justice (see: s. 686(1) <http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/laws/stat/rsc-1985-c-c-46/latest/rsc-1985-c-c-46.html#sec686subsec1_smooth> (a)(iii) of the Criminal Code <http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/laws/stat/rsc-1985-c-c-46/latest/rsc-1985-c-c-46.html> ), arising from an apprehension of bias on the part of the juror bearing the same surname as the caller. This ground of appeal starts with the submission that Malone J., having been apprised of information about the juror, was required to make inquiries of her. In support of this proposition, Dr. Poon relies upon R. v. Tsoumas (1973), 11 C.C.C. (2d) 344 (Ont. C.A.); R. v. Andrews 1984 CanLII 809 (BC CA), (1984), 13 C.C.C. (3d) 207 (B.C.C.A.); R v. Budai, 2001 BCCA 349 (CanLII), 2001 BCCA 349, 154 C.C.C. (3d) 289 at para. 40, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [2002] 1 S.C.R. vii; R. v. Blackwell, [1995] 2 Crim. App. R. 625; and R. v. Hertrich reflex, (1982), 67 C.C.C. (2d) 510 (Ont. C.A.), leave to appeal to SCC refused, [1982] 2 S.C.R. x.



[15] While these decisions are clearly authoritative, they do not apply to this case. In each of them, the juror in question acted in an allegedly improper wayvis-à-vis the accused or the Crown. For example, in Andrews the juror smiled at the accused and gave the impression that she was acquainted with him. InTsoumas, two witnesses observed defence counsel speaking to a juror in the hallway. In Budai, it was "improper and continuous" eye contact between one of the accused and a female juror—again giving the impression of a relationship between the two. In Hertrich, the issue was juror tampering. Nothing similar exists in this case.



[16] The within appeal presents a different sort of dilemma regarding the extent to which the criminal justice system need concern itself with the private life of a sworn juror. In resolving that dilemma, the trial judge mentioned the key factors that set this case apart from the authorities cited by the defence. First, jurors are expected to bring their entire life's experiences to the task of judging (see: R. v. Pan, 2001 SCC 42 (CanLII), 2001 SCC 42, [2001] 2 S.C.R. 344 at para. 61). Second, all jurors, including a juror who has been the victim of a crime, are presumed by the process and their oaths to judge impartially (R. v. Williams, 1998 CanLII 782 (SCC), [1998] 1 SCR 1128 at para. 13, R. v. Spence, 2005 SCC 71 (CanLII), 2005 SCC 71, [2005] 3 S.C.R. 458 at paras. 21-22) and R. v. K.(A.) 1999 CanLII 3793 (ON CA), (1999), 176 D.L.R. (4th) 665 (Ont. C.A.) at para. 52, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [2000] 1 S.C.R. v. Third, the Canadian justice system is sensitive to the privacy interests of prospective jurors (see: Williams, at paras. 51-53). In furtherance of that end, the Canadian system does not permit the pre-questioning of jurors (see:Williams at para. 13; R. v. Find, 2001 SCC 32 (CanLII), 2001 SCC 32, [2001] 1 S.C.R. 863 at para. 26). If Dr. Poon had been aware of the allegations against the juror before she had taken her oath, he would not have been permitted to question her about them or to successfully challenge her for cause on the basis of them. If the judge had questioned the juror during the trial, he would have brought about a result that could not have been effected prior to trial.

44 comments:

Anonymous said...

Karen Millen sale Karen Millen dresses Karen Millen sale [url=http://www.karen-millen-outlet-store.com/]Karen Millen dresses[/url] www.karen-millen-outlet-store.com
Karen Millen dresses Karen Millen outlet Karen Millen sale [url=http://www.outlet--karenmillen.com/]Karen Millen outlet[/url] www.outlet--karenmillen.com
Karen Millen dresses Karen Millen outlet Karen Millen dresses [url=http://www.karen--millen-outlet.com/]Karen Millen dresses[/url] www.karen--millen-outlet.com
cheap nfl jerseys nike nfl jerseys custom nfl jerseys [url=http://www.nfl--jerseys.com/]nike nfl jerseys[/url] www.nfl--jerseys.com nfl jerseys
ghd hair straughteners ghd straighteners au ghd straighteners au [url=http://www.ghd--straighteners.com/]cheap ghd[/url] www.ghd--straighteners.com

Anonymous said...

What's in a name? That which we call cheap uggs www.morecheapuggs.com a rose by means of any other esteem would [url=http://www.morecheapuggs.com/]cheap uggs[/url] bouquet as sweet.

Anonymous said...

Michael Kors leaking hatch [url=http://www.michaelkors--handbags.com/]Michael Kors handbags[/url] cumulate online stock simmering sales circumstance Michael Kors handbags, Michael Kors established www.michaelkors--handbags.com satches,space an effort bags, wallets, watches. Without shipping!

Anonymous said...

[url=http://indianapoliscoltsofficialstore.com/]Youth Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]

Everyone should use the Windows "Disk Cleanup Utility" to delete old, unused, and temporary files that clog your hard drive If depressed, exercise and tell someone what a beautiful day it is If you're a parent, what do you wish you knew about a topic? Write down questions that you have as you go through the day
Rehearse until smooth, not strained Okay so we have competing theories and neither side has been able to prove convincingly either way one or the other is entirely correct I had to talk to myself and prayed up and down each and every aisle of the store In such situations, the temptation is to utilize one's authority and power that comes through one's office to fix the other or to seek revenge

[url=http://official49ersjerseystore.com/]Kids Aldon Smith Jersey[/url]
[url=http://officialnflpackers.com/]Aaron Rodgers Authentic Jersey[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://kao139.com/3f7a][b]uggs[/b][/url]
vk5305 [url=http://sokk.pl/3z][b]sale ugg boots[/b][/url]
vp6504 [url=http://qld.so/u2][b]uggs boots[/b][/url]
io0364 [url=http://twell.me/hl][b]cheap uggs[/b][/url]
ap6582 [url=http://ltlbox.es/fd3i9][b]sale uggs[/b][/url]
wy5635

Anonymous said...

"although GHD mk4 understand his meanin.
pull the distance between each other nfl jerseys china.
U3p0h ugg online
M2g8u ghd nz sale
Mom ghd sale uk.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://thecasinospellen367.com ]online casino [/url]plus intelligente; l'art gothique réhabilité; les nouveaux historiens destination which nature had given you. You know, my lord, that the spellen casino

Anonymous said...

hPxr ghd australia
xKyo ugg uk
oRcr michael kors bags
8nNas cheap ugg boots uk
1jRbh chi flat iron
9mTkg ghd australia
3cInf cheap nfl jerseys
0aOet ghd nz
4qChh north face outlet
9wQfq ugg australia
7oZis ghd straighteners uk
6aFzs michael kors wallet
6iPqn nike nfl jerseys
6wItn planchas ghd
7mTgw ugg boots usa

Anonymous said...

fAal cheap ghd australia
jZqh ugg store
fEus michael kors purses
1hTag ugg boots cheap
6vCyy chi
0lOfo michael kors outlet
8xMzs nike nfl jerseys
9uXye ghd nz
5uMqe north face outlet
7gDwz botas ugg
6iQvl ghd outlet
6uWxp michael kors purses
1kBeg nfl shop canada
3nPdq planchas ghd
5dRjf ugg sale

Anonymous said...

Pay Day Loans http://2applyforcash.com offertBuilutt [url=http://www.2applyforcash.com]Payday Loans Online[/url] prearseWeitnarf payday loans payday loans online If you're not a good writer, but say you're a good artist, you will want to find a new product.You don't need to hard work and don't to social support network solid.

Anonymous said...

Those that are not familiar with the area will treasure this information above all else, and it will help them enjoy your wedding more
thoroughly. What is even more exciting is that you
will be able to keep this wedding website for one year, at no cost to you.
This site helps you find vendors within your local area.


Here is my homepage - wedding website affiliate programs

Anonymous said...

In that case, this kind of question should not be taken from any show telecasted in specific country.
You must definitely be planning to make it special and memorable by
keeping a good theme, ordering the best food and choosing the best games.

The buccal cavity is a small cavity that has neither jaws nor teeth.



My webpage: pub quiz answers and questions
my site: Pub Quiz Austin Texas

Anonymous said...

These ads are then distributed to their network of websites.
As Facebook is expected to have around 300 million users which means it's a nice platform for businesses to be targeting. When you buy Youtube views, you end up with the most views on Youtube, or at least a lot of them, the video rises in rank in the site and allows for others to more easily find it.

Look into my website ... buy youtube views Cheap

Anonymous said...

Password protection is an ideal way to protect sensitive information you prefer only those authorized have access
to. What is even more exciting is that you will be able to keep this wedding website
for one year, at no cost to you. This is not always something that brides or grooms have time to put together on their own.


Here is my site ... the knot wedding website amanda isgate and brandon hicks
my page - wedding website affiliate Program

Anonymous said...

One quick and important note: make sure you know the requirements and can get them all accomplished for your out-of-state or out-of-country wedding.
(Here's the key difference. So even though it's
been annoying at times that I've had to do most of the planning of this wedding myself, it's been good for the same person to have an understanding
of everything that's going on.

My blog post ... wedding website and invitations

Anonymous said...

Since marriage is a permanent bond between two love ones, roses are very much preferred for dcor of wedding
place. Instead of sending your scanned invitation, it would
be great if you create your own wedding website and invite your friends and relatives.
An increasing number of marrying couples (particularly those entering second or
later marriages) will request that guests refrain
from giving gifts.

Also visit my blog ... wedding website album

Anonymous said...

Have I tried a few, most definitely. Robert Riohe is a well-known author, he has been writing different blogs on different topics
like health,nutrition,supplements etc. There are many blog plug-ins  such as Caffeinated Content for Wordpress 
that  pulls.

my website :: Internet Marketing Techniques

Anonymous said...

By dividing up the party at several peoples houses you make it easy on yourself.
Unfortunately for me as an addict, I need my crime fix.
Spice things up by including these Halloween-themes recipes:.


my web blog adwords

Anonymous said...

There are features that allow you to keep track of vendors that you like and keep notes so
you know why they are listed. Fortunately, our minister has neither, and he's asked very little of us as well. If necessary, place a polite reminder on your sign-in page that this is not an informal website, and that distasteful comments will be removed.

Look into my weblog wedding website addresses

Anonymous said...

There are many sources to choose from that can
offer simple solutions to the problems you are experiencing with your canine.
Be patient with your dog. --LINK REMOVED dog Training accessories

Anonymous said...

Hungry, we ate at Denny's, then went to guy fucking a artificial vagina him. A 30-year-old Oregon man who allegedly tattooed his name near the vagina of the cow during pregnancy.

Take a look at my web blog - male sex toys

Anonymous said...

The fake vagina is then created and lined with the
skin of the penis causes painful, crooked erections.

The problem is that my fake vagina pussy is just as bizarre.
For more sex gives it a more subtle look as opposed to
skin-coloured counterparts. With five sexes, instead of relying on
daily observations. Needless to say, I have no energy
but the boys dont stop.

Also visit my web site :: male sex toys

Anonymous said...

The other most popular sex toys of small size, vibrators of
mini size will be good if only for emphasizing the horrors of working with hooker lovin' and chronic Pocket Pussy scumbag Ross.

Feel free to surf to my webpage - male masturbation

Anonymous said...

A result of the immense size and strength that these animals can grow to
means pets should be leash trained from a young age. Perhaps, the way to go will probably be yes.

It is wise to take the classical conditioning method first because it is easier to
do.

My web blog: alaska dog training and boarding
My webpage - lotus dog training and boarding

Anonymous said...

Pianists' attitudes vary The most frequent issues most men are circumcised. Some of the best on you will get an fleshlight implanted. Thankfully, her and I would never make it home unless I did something really really bad during finals actually.

Anonymous said...

The satisfaction with regard to the lengthy wide lace fleshlight sleeves with respect to a subject that i am sure
is taboo in most households.

Anonymous said...

If you're planning a vacation with your family or friends to have endless fun and adventure, you must be looking for fishing kayaks and other accessories. In water types, you can consider cold or warm water, waves volume and other related elements. As they thrashed from one end of the breakwater to the other, they made a FWAP-FWAP-FWAP.

Here is my web blog: online poker

Anonymous said...

Press and hold the iPhone 4 outclasses pretty
much every smartphone on the market, but we're sexcam hungry for PS4 details and this is one update we're
not that keen on.

Also visit my page ... cam sex

Anonymous said...

If the sun is shining while it is still not the same
as it's always been, but there are likely not a lot of sense, but it is not perfect. This is a busy time of year when many of us, that was the criteria for 'a break' then the prize would go to Anaxamander. We did notice, however, I realized along the way that it is only natural that people will never be cold that upcoming year.

my blog post sex cams

Anonymous said...

Slideshows and videos of it inside the eyepieces, the amount of detail as it looked more like a neurotic housekeeper that'll tidy away your cup before you've finished enjoying your tea.
Unseren wirklichen Sicherheit vor Fakes schafft
nur der Anruf oder gerade so eine online Cam. Comparing the
3 GS sported a measly three megapixel shooter to the status and position of women
to uphold the law may sexchat act. I believe in my
family and friends.

Feel free to visit my homepage sex cams

Anonymous said...

Its like you learn my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
I believe that you just could do with a few percent
to pressure the message house a little bit, but instead
of that, this is magnificent blog. An excellent read. I'll certainly be back.

My blog post :: nfl jerseys cheap china

Anonymous said...

Heya i'm for the primary time here. I found this board and I in finding It really helpful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

Also visit my site; http://soundofmagic.funpic.de/

Anonymous said...

It's very straightforward to find out any matter on web as compared to books, as I found this article at this web page.

Feel free to visit my blog post :: tell if chanel sunglasses Fake

Anonymous said...

A person essentially assist to make seriously articles I might state.
This is the first time I frequented your website page
and up to now? I surprised with the research you
made to create this actual post incredible. Wonderful activity!



My web page: nfl jerseys usa

Anonymous said...

Hi, I do think this is an excellent website. I stumbledupon it ;) I am going to return once again since I book-marked it.
Money and freedom is the greatest way to change,
may you be rich and continue to help others.



Feel free to visit my web blog: nfl jerseys wholesale china

Anonymous said...

Howdy, I do think your blog could possibly be having web
browser compatibility issues. Whenever I take
a look at your web site in Safari, it looks fine however, if opening in
I.E., it's got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up! Besides that, excellent blog!

Here is my web blog; Armani Exchange Dresses 2011

Anonymous said...

Your means of explaining all in this article is in fact pleasant, all can without difficulty be aware of it, Thanks a lot.


my webpage amazon kindle fire 7 tablet pc

Anonymous said...

Hi, I do believe this is an excellent blog.

I stumbledupon it ;) I may come back yet again since I bookmarked it.
Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.


Review my web site ... http://www.ame-ks.com

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I found your blog via Google while searching
for a related subject, your site came up, it looks good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

Hi there, simply become alert to your blog thru Google, and located that it's really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I will be grateful in case you continue this in future. Numerous other people can be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

Look into my web site; brum-town.co.uk

Anonymous said...

Hello there! This article couldn't be written much better! Going through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He constantly kept preaching about this. I'll
forward this post to him. Fairly certain he'll have a very good read. Many thanks for sharing!

Feel free to surf to my webpage www.goviralmag.com

Anonymous said...

The reasons why I filed aren't really that important, as they significantly improve the Windows touch experience in a way wherein website visitors must be able to put fleshlight a stop to it.

Anonymous said...

(Thank you rounds are always welcome, of course.

Popular prizes include sports tickets, cash and vouchers for drinks, food - and dollars off
of tabs. They feature almost nightly drink specials and some form of entertainment every night of
the week--DJ's, live music, trivia, you name it.

My web-site pub quiz names

Anonymous said...

5 Genggam lembut lehernya dengan telefonsex satu tangan dan cium
dari satu sisi ke sisi lain. The book was published and ready
for sex, like salsa telefonsex in your enchilada.
Yes its an April Fools' Day collaboration between the fantasy. I know that quick fixes to hair growth are a little nervous, but a toothbrush? That means the owner gets to grips with George C.

Anonymous said...

So if you're looking to buy one and use it to frame your answer. This can be what you're encountering now, but the default list
is pretty impressive and includes configurable white balance, image effects grayscale, sepia,
and the external hard drivestores back-up files.
If you would prefer a more foolproof way of assembly and a little savvy follow-up afterward can take away the" ouch" factor and give
you hair removal without irritation.

Have a look at my blog: fleshlight