Thursday, September 27, 2012

Publication ban proper to protect identity of bullied person however nonidentifying information to be made public

A.B. v. Bragg Communications Inc., 2012 SCC 46 was just released.  The Supreme Court upholds publication bans insofar as they protect the identity of people subjected to bullying on the basis that the specific identity is but a “sliver” of information.  Nonidentifying information however, is to be made public, as there is no harmful impact on the bullied person since the information cannot be connected to the bullied person.  The public’s right to open courts –and press freedom – therefore prevail with respect to the nonidentifying content. The Court writes:

 

[10]                          A.B.’s appeal to this Court is based on what she says is the failure to properly balance the competitive risks in this case: the harm inherent in revealing her identity versus the risk of harm to the open court principle in allowing her to proceed anonymously and under a publication ban.  Unless her privacy is protected, she argued, young victims of sexualized cyberbullying like her will refuse to proceed with their protective claims and will, as a result, be denied access to justice.

 

[11]                          The open court principle requires that court proceedings presumptively be open and accessible to the public and to the media.  This principle has been described as a “hallmark of a democratic society” (Vancouver Sun (Re),  [2004] 2 S.C.R. 332, at para. 23) and is inextricably tied to freedom of expression.  A.B. requested two restrictions on the open court principle: the right to proceed anonymously and a publication ban on the content of the fake Facebook profile.  The inquiry is into whether each of these measures is necessary to protect an important legal interest and impairs free expression as little as possible.  If alternative measures can just as effectively protect the interests engaged, the restriction is unjustified.   If no such alternatives exist, the inquiry turns to whether the proper balance was struck between the open court principle and the privacy rights of the girl: Dagenais v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp., [1994] 3 S.C.R. 835; R. v. Mentuck, [2001] 3 S.C.R. 442.

 

[12]                          The Halifax Herald and Global Television did not appear in the proceedings before this Court.  Their “position” was, however, ably advanced by an amicus curiae.  In his view, like the Court of Appeal, the mere fact of the girl’s age did not, in the absence of evidence of specific harm to her, trump the open court principle and freedom of the press.

 

[13]                          Since Edmonton Journal v. Alberta (Attorney General), [1989] 2 S.C.R. 1326, the critical importance of the open court principle and a free press has been tenaciously embedded in the jurisprudence and need not be further revisited here.  What does need some exploration, however, are the interests said to justify restricting such access in this case: privacy and the protection of children from cyberbullying.  These interests must be shown to be sufficiently compelling to warrant restrictions on freedom of the press and open courts.  As Dickson J. noted in Attorney General of Nova Scotia v. MacIntyre, [1982] 1 S.C.R. 175, there are cases in which the protection of social values must prevail over openness (pp. 186-87).

 

[14]                            The girl’s privacy interests in this case are tied both to her age and to the nature of the victimization she seeks protection from.  It is not merely a question of her privacy, but of her privacy from the relentlessly intrusive humiliation of sexualized online bullying:  Carole Lucock and Michael Yeo, “Naming Names: The Pseudonym in the Name of the Law” (2006), 3 U. Ottawa L. & Tech. J. 53, at pp. 72-73; Karen Eltis, “The Judicial System in the Digital Age: Revisiting the Relationship between Privacy and Accessibility in the Cyber Context” (2011), 56, McGill L.J. 289, at p. 302.

 

[15]                          The amicus curiae pointed to the absence of evidence of harm from the girl about her own emotional vulnerability.  But, while evidence of a direct, harmful consequence to an individual applicant is relevant, courts may also conclude that there is objectively discernable harm.

 

[16]                          This Court found objective harm, for example, in upholding the constitutionality of Quebec’s Rules of Practice that limited the media’s ability to film, take photographs, and conduct interviews in relation to legal proceedings (in Canadian Broadcasting Corp. v. Canada (Attorney General), [2011] 1 S.C.R. 19), and in prohibiting the media from broadcasting a video exhibit (in Canadian Broadcasting Corp. v. The Queen, [2011] 1 S.C.R. 65).  In the former, Deschamps J. held (at para. 56) that the Dagenais/Mentuck test requires neither more nor less than the one from R. v. Oakes, [1986] 1 S.C.R. 103.  In other words, absent scientific or empirical evidence of the necessity of restricting access, the court can find harm by applying reason and logic: RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1995] 3 S.C.R. 199, at para. 72; Thomson Newspapers Co. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1998] 1 S.C.R. 877, at para. 91.

 

[17]                          Recognition of the inherent vulnerability of children has consistent and deep roots in Canadian law.  This results in protection for young people’s privacy under the Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46 (s. 486), the Youth Criminal Justice Act, S.C. 2002, c. 1 (s. 110), and child welfare legislation, not to mention international protections such as the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Can. T.S. 1992 No. 3, all based on age, not the sensitivity of the particular child.   As a result, in an application involving sexualized cyberbullying, there is no need for a particular child to demonstrate that she personally conforms to this legal paradigm.  The law attributes the heightened vulnerability based on chronology, not temperament: See R. v. D.B., [2008] 2 S.C.R. 3, at paras. 41, 61 and 84-87; R. v. Sharpe, [2001] 1 S.C.R. 45, at paras. 170-74.

 

[18]                          This led Cohen J. in Toronto Star Newspaper Ltd. v. Ontario, 2012 ONCJ 27 (Can LII), to explain the importance of privacy in the specific context of young persons who are participants in the justice system:

 

     The concern to avoid labeling and stigmatization is essential to an understanding of why the protection of privacy is such an important value in the Act.  However it is not the only explanation. The value of the privacy of young persons under the Act has deeper roots than exclusively pragmatic considerations would suggest. We must also look to the Charter, because the protection of privacy of young persons has undoubted constitutional significance.

 

 

     Privacy is recognized in Canadian constitutional jurisprudence as implicating liberty and security interests. In Dyment, the court stated that privacy is worthy of constitutional protection because it is “grounded in man’s physical and moral autonomy,” is “essential for the well-being of the individual,” and is “at the heart of liberty in a modern state” (para. 17).  These considerations apply equally if not more strongly in the case of young persons.  Furthermore, the constitutional protection of privacy embraces the privacy of young persons, not only as an aspect of their rights under section 7 and 8 of the Charter, but by virtue of the presumption of their diminished moral culpability, which has been found to be a principle of fundamental justice under the Charter.

 

. . .

 

     [T]he protection of the privacy of young persons fosters respect for dignity, personal integrity and autonomy of the young person.  [Emphasis added; paras. 40-41 and 44.]

 

[19]                          And in R. v. L. (D.O.), [1993] 4 S.C.R. 419, L’Heureux-Dubé J. upheld the constitutionality of the Criminal Code provisions that allowed for the admission of video tape evidence from child complainants in sexual assault cases, based on the need to reduce the stress and trauma suffered by child complainants in the criminal justice system: pp. 445-46; see also Doe v. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints in Canada, 2003 ABQB 794, 341 A.R. 395, at para. 9.

 

[20]                            It is logical to infer that children may suffer harm through cyberbullying.  Such a conclusion is consistent with the psychological toxicity of the phenomenon described in the Report of the Nova Scotia Task Force on Bullying and Cyberbullying, chaired by Prof. A. Wayne MacKay, the first provincial task force focussed on online bullying: (Respectful and Responsible Relationships: There’s No App for That: The Report of the Nova Scotia Task Force on Bullying and Cyberbullying (2012)).  The Task Force was created as a result of “[a] tragic series of youth suicides” (p. 4).

 

[21]                          The Report defined bullying as

 

 

. . . behaviour that is intended to cause, or should be known to cause, fear, intimidation, humiliation, distress or other forms of harm to another person’s body, feelings, self-esteem, reputation or property.  Bullying can be direct or indirect, and can take place by written, verbal, physical or electronic means, or any other form of expression. [pp. 42-43]

 

Its harmful consequences were described as “extensive”, including loss of self-esteem, anxiety, fear and school drop-outs (p. 4).  Moreover, victims of bullying were almost twice as likely to report that they attempted suicide compared to young people who had not been bullied (at p. 86): See also  R. v. R.(W.), 2010 ONCJ 526 (Can LII), at paras. 11 and 16, and “Cyberbullying: A Growing Problem”, Science Daily (February 22, 2010, online).

 

[22]                          The Report also noted that cyberbullying can be particularly harmful because the content can be spread widely, quickly — and anonymously:

 

The immediacy and broad reach of modern electronic technology has made bullying easier, faster, more prevalent, and crueller than ever before.

 

. . . cyber-bullying follows you home and into your bedroom; you can never feel safe, it is “non-stop bullying”. . . . cyberbullying is particularly insidious because it invades the home where children normally feel safe, and it is constant and inescapable because victims can be reached at all times and in all places.

 

The anonymity available to cyberbullies complicates the picture further as it removes the traditional requirement for a power imbalance between the bully and victim, and makes it difficult to prove the identity of the perpetrator.  Anonymity allows people who might not otherwise engage in bullying behaviour the opportunity to do so with less chance of repercussion. . . .

 

. . . The cyber-world provides bullies with a vast unsupervised public playground . . . . [pp. 11-12]

 

[23]                          In addition to the psychological harm of cyberbullying, we must consider the resulting inevitable harm to children — and the administration of justice — if they decline to take steps to protect themselves because of the risk of further harm from public disclosure.

 

[24]                           Professor MacKay’s Report is consistent with the inference that, absent a grant of anonymity, a bullied child may not pursue responsive legal action.  He notes that half of all bullying goes unreported, largely out of fear that reporting will not be met with solutions or understanding sufficient to overcome the fear of retaliation: p. 10.  One of his recommendations, as a result, was that mechanisms be developed to report cyberbullying anonymously (p. 66; Appendix E; see also Peter A. Winn, “Online Court Records: Balancing Judicial Accountability and Privacy in an Age of Electronic Information” (2004), 79 Wash. L. Rev. 307, at p. 328).

 

[25]                          In the context of sexual assault, this Court has already recognized that protecting a victim’s privacy encourages reporting: Canadian Newspapers Co. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1988] 2 S.C.R. 122.  It does not take much of an analytical leap to conclude that the likelihood of a child protecting himself or herself from bullying will be greatly enhanced if the protection can be sought anonymously.  As the Kids Help Phone factum constructively notes (at para. 16), protecting children’s anonymity could help ensure that they will seek therapeutic assistance and other remedies, including legal remedies where appropriate.  In particular, “[w]hile media publicity is likely to have a negative effect on all victims, there is evidence to be particularly concerned about child victims. . . . Child victims need to be able to trust that their privacy will be protected as much as possible by those whom they have turned to for help”: Lisa M. Jones, David Finkelhor and Jessica Beckwith, “Protecting victims’ identities in press coverage of child victimization” (2010), 11 Journalism 347, at pp. 349-50.

 

[26]                          Studies have confirmed that allowing the names of child victims and other identifying information to appear in the media can exacerbate trauma, complicate recovery, discourage future disclosures, and inhibit cooperation with authorities.  (See e.g., UNICEF Innocenti Research Centre, Child Safety Online: Global challenges and strategies (2011), at pp. 15–16; and R. v. D.H., 2002 BCPC 464 (Can LII), at para. 8).

 

[27]                          If we value the right of children to protect themselves from bullying, cyber or otherwise, if common sense and the evidence persuade us that young victims of sexualized bullying are particularly vulnerable to the harms of revictimization upon publication, and if we accept that the right to protection will disappear for most children without the further protection of anonymity, we are compellingly drawn in this case to allowing A.B.’s anonymous legal pursuit of the identity of her cyberbully.

 

[28]                          The answer to the other side of the balancing inquiry — what are the countervailing harms to the open courts principle and freedom of the press — has already been decided by this Court in Canadian Newspapers.  In that case, the constitutionality of the provision in the Criminal Code prohibiting disclosure of the identity of sexual assault complainants was challenged on the basis that its mandatory nature unduly restricted freedom of the press.  In upholding the constitutionality of the provision, Lamer J. observed that:

 

            While freedom of the press is nonetheless an important value in our democratic society which should not be hampered lightly, it must be recognized that the limits imposed by [prohibiting identity disclosure] on the media’s rights are minimal. . . . Nothing prevents the media from being present at the hearing and reporting the facts of the case and the conduct of the trial.  Only information likely to reveal the complainant’s identity is concealed from the public. [Emphasis added; p. 133.]

In other words, the harm has been found to be “minimal”.  This perspective of the relative insignificance of knowing a party’s identity was confirmed by Binnie J. in F.N. where he referred to identity in the context of the Young Offenders legislation as being merely a “sliver of information”: F.N. (Re), [2000] 1 S.C.R. 880, at para. 12.

 

[29]                          The acknowledgment of the relative unimportance of the identity of a sexual assault victim is a complete answer to the argument that the non-disclosure of the identity of a young victim of online sexualized bullying is harmful to the exercise of press freedom or the open courts principle.  Canadian Newspapers clearly establishes that the benefits of protecting such victims through anonymity outweigh the risk to the open court principle.

 

[30]                          On the other hand, as in Canadian Newspapers, once A.B.’s identity is protected through her right to proceed anonymously, there seems to me to be little justification for a publication ban on the non-identifying content of the fake Facebook profile.  If the non-identifying information is made public, there is no harmful impact since the information cannot be connected to A.B.  The public’s right to open courts and press freedom therefore prevail with respect to the non-identifying Facebook content.

39 comments:

Annie Valdez said...

Privacy is very very important to everyone. If there are cases that involves privacy such as cyber bullying and identity theft, concerns about it must be opened up to the victims in a very polite manner.

Annie Valdez

Anonymous said...

Hi there your web site url: http://www.blogger.
com/comment.g?blogID=4937285970642106606&postID=5132406659851921804 seems to be redirecting to
a completely different website when I click the home-page link.
You may want to have this checked.

Feel free to surf to my web blog vacation rental property tax deductions

Anonymous said...

Hello! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to
give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading through your posts.
Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the
same subjects? Thank you so much!

my page bryant furnace repair
my page - furnace brands names

Anonymous said...

Gday, I am new to blogging and websites in general and was curious about
how you got the "www" included in your web address name?

I see your domain, "http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=4937285970642106606&postID=5132406659851921804"
has the www and my domain looks like, "http://mydomain.com".
Do you know the correct way I can alter this? I'm using Wordpress. Thank you so much

My web blog - electric furnace brands

Anonymous said...

With havin so much written content do you ever run into any issues of plagorism or copyright
violation? My blog has a lot of exclusive content I've either authored myself or outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all over the internet without my agreement. Do you know any ways to help reduce content from being ripped off? I'd genuinely
appreciate it.

my blog: http://www.youtube.com/

Anonymous said...

Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to
assist with Search Engine Optimization? I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not seeing very good results.
If you know of any please share. Kudos!

Also visit my web page - soccer duffel bags for girls

Anonymous said...

Hi just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let
you know a few of the pictures aren't loading properly. I'm not sure why but I
think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different browsers and both show the same outcome.

my weblog plus size sports bras for running

Anonymous said...

Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your
article seem to be running off the screen in Ie. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post to let you know.
The design look great though! Hope you get the problem solved soon.

Kudos

Also visit my webpage - http://beauirwin1126.insanejournal.com

Anonymous said...

Wonderful blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo
News? I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Many thanks

Here is my site: capacadie.Com

Anonymous said...

Today, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just
so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now destroyed and she has 83 views.

I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it
with someone!

Feel free to surf to my website ... digital camera buying guide for beginners

Anonymous said...

Woah! I'm really digging the template/theme of this website. It's simple, yet effective.
A lot of times it's hard to get that "perfect balance" between user friendliness and appearance. I must say that you've done a fantastic job with this.

Also, the blog loads extremely quick for me on Internet explorer.

Superb Blog!

Feel free to surf to my weblog ... http://www.femmes-emploi.fr/

Anonymous said...

Hey! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering
which blog platform are you using for this site?
I'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had problems with hackers and I'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

Also visit my page ... nand flash memory basics

Anonymous said...

I'm curious to find out what blog platform you happen to be using? I'm experiencing some minor security problems with my latest
site and I'd like to find something more risk-free. Do you have any solutions?

Check out my homepage ethernet cable 100 ft price

Anonymous said...

I am starting up a new online website directory and was wondering if I can submit your site?
I'm trying to grow my directory gradually by hand so that it maintains top quality. I'll make sure and put
your website in the best category and I'll also use, "Blogger: Morton's Musings" as your anchor text. Please be sure to let me know if this is ok with you by emailing me at: joyce-pino@yahoo.de. Thanks!

my web-site - ballet shoes book author

Anonymous said...

Hi. I'm sorry to trouble you but I ran across your blog and noticed you're using the exact same template as me.

The only issue is on my website, I'm battling to get the layout looking like yours. Would you mind emailing me at: blancaburks@gmail.com so I can get this figured out. By the way I have bookmarked your site: http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=4937285970642106606&postID=5132406659851921804 and will be visiting frequently. Thanks!

Look into my homepage; ballet shoes movie emma watson

Anonymous said...

Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against
hackers? I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard on.
Any recommendations?

Feel free to surf to my web site http://www.writerscafe.org/bra93flavor

Anonymous said...

Hello! I've been reading your website for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Austin Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the fantastic job!

Feel free to surf to my site - furnished apartments boston

Anonymous said...

Ground cover can be added to pedophile the landscape.

Place organic kitchen waste, as well as yard waste
such as grass clippings, leaves, and the like into a compost bin.
When ordering mulch, find out what the delivery cost is and compare it between companies before ordering.


Also visit my weblog :: mulching

Anonymous said...

Ground cover can be added to pedophile the landscape.
Place organic kitchen waste, as well as yard waste such as grass
clippings, leaves, and the like into a compost bin.
When ordering mulch, find out what the delivery cost is and compare it between companies before ordering.



Look into my webpage - mulching

Anonymous said...

We absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post's to be exactly what I'm looking for.
can you offer guest writers to write content available for you?
I wouldn't mind creating a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome web site!

Feel free to visit my web site vacation rentals by owners naples florida

Anonymous said...

XqpGjwIvwFlr [url=http://nike114.webnode.jp/]nike air[/url] IfwLzpZbfAoq [url=http://sougyokuka8.webnode.jp/]nike[/url]HwmQutLccEyz [url=http://sougyokuka6.webnode.jp/]ナイキシューズ[/url] UpqFbsHxwYce [url=http://sougyokuka4.webnode.jp/]スニーカーナイキ[/url]AmrYovQxrBeh [url=http://sougyokuka0.webnode.jp/]nike ランニング[/url]YvgMdkMmrXai [url=http://sougyokuka9.webnode.jp/]nike free[/url]QdbCcuJqdWjp [url=http://nikenne.seesaa.net/]ナイキ[/url]

[url=http://gucci47.webnode.jp/]グッチ gucci[/url]JsvGyiOukUdl [url=http://gucci35.webnode.jp/]gucci 財布[/url]ZcgZlsBwfTtk [url=http://gucci8.webnode.jp/] バッグ gucci[/url]GaySqcSicZuw [url=http://gucci66.webnode.jp/]gucci[/url]
WvqYkwWhzBdk

TivMloSiiLqi [url=https://mizuno0.webnode.jp/]mizuno ミズノ[/url] TvhQreTyhDdr [url=https://mizuno9.webnode.jp/]ミズノゴルフ[/url] NhmFluHeqRbm [url=https://mizuno90.webnode.jp/]ゴルフ ミズノ[/url]LueRmbKvaGpe [url=https://mizuno51.webnode.jp/]ミズノゴルフ[/url]

Anonymous said...

DrbGzhRonIwv
[url=http://gucci9.webnode.jp/]gucci アウトレット[/url] OsbPvuWzsSvt [url=http://chloe78.webnode.jp/]クロエ[/url] NyhDfbPufUaa[url=http://chloe21.webnode.jp/]see by chloe[/url]WglLyaCboLiv [url=http://chloe53.webnode.jp/]財布 クロエ[/url]NkoOjxVshEvd [url=http://chanel65.webnode.jp/]シャネル[/url]NvzNovHbeNul [url=http://chanel62.webnode.jp/]chanel バッグ[/url] XpkIsiZqnJer[url=http://chanel27.webnode.jp/]chanel 財布[/url]

[url=http://gucci85.webnode.jp/]グッチ[/url]KexFzzErnKvr [url=http://gucci01.webnode.jp/]財布 gucci[/url]CdtFjhSfvZyi [url=http://gucci-as.webnode.jp/]gucci メンズ[/url]
CsrAcsCkjCog

TfpYkkRwhZsl
[url=http://guccib.webnode.jp/] バック グッチ[/url]RgjSflMmdGqq [url=http://gucciy.webnode.jp/]グッチ アウトレット[/url]WizCwmNmuHsx [url=http://gucci-as8.webnode.jp/]グッチ アウトレット[/url] WaiPshCzaUtz [url=http://gucci-as3.webnode.jp/]gucci バック[/url]RufAhxPqnBce [url=http://gucci28.webnode.jp/] gucci 財布 メンズ[/url]OdqXkvNupWrj [url=http://gucci07.webnode.jp/]gucci バック[/url]EngPfqJfnPme [url=http://gucci44.webnode.jp/] gucci[/url]YyoVzcChnNcl[url=http://gucci92.webnode.jp/]gucci アウトレット[/url]GoyXleOvaLsf [url=http://gucci117.webnode.jp/]gucci アウトレット[/url]SsrTqzLzvXld[url=http://gucci968.webnode.jp/]gucci アウトレット[/url]

Anonymous said...

Many people argue that eating too many plants grown with commercial fertilizers
or pesticides can cause health problems. When you're preparing your planting area, just mix the soil with about three inches of organic compost. Again, using companion planting techniques will help your organic garden flourish.

Also visit my web page: income

Anonymous said...

The newspapers help readers to get the hottest updated and happenings around the world.
I suffered a lot of bullying and some sexual abuse
and it compounded my identity problem. He becomes a different
person once he dons his uniform to the sound of the orchestra
warming up. Newspapers act as the ideal method of public relations due to its strength as the best way of communication.
A Christian newspaperis also associated with various charitable institutions
and churches and organizes fund raising events to help and aid such institutions.



Feel free to visit my web page - click here

Anonymous said...

Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not seeing very
good gains. If you know of any please share.

Kudos!

Feel free to surf to my webpage: d2pak eagle 3d

Anonymous said...

Heya great website! Does running a blog like this require a lot of work?
I've no expertise in programming but I had been hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyway, should you have any ideas or techniques for new blog owners please share. I understand this is off subject but I just wanted to ask. Thank you!

Feel free to surf to my blog post :: http://www.youtube.com

Anonymous said...

There are many designer [url=http://burberry-sale.manifo.com]burberry online[/url] that are available for sale. One of these [url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/]burberry outlet[/url] is really a handbag. creative designers can be purchased at expensive costs. [url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/burberry-women-tote-bag-c-14.html]burberry outlet[/url] women choosing replica [url=http://longchampsoldes.over-blog.com]longchamp pliage[/url]. This particular will go especially for the actual women that do not want to invest most of their hard-earned cash on a luxurious. choose a geniune [url=http://sacsguess.over-blog.com]sacs guess[/url] instead. It is possible to locate real [url=http://sacsmichaelkors.over-blog.com]Sac à main michael kors[/url], whenever you understand finding. [url=http://isabelmarantsneakersfr.over-blog.com]isabel marant collection[/url]. You might be happy to know buy a custom purse.
QsoFdl There are many retailers promoting handbags in order to women, who are fashion-slaves. [url=http://www.sacamainlongchamps.devhub.com]sac longchamps[/url] KshGka XitMlz [url=http://www.isabelmarantsneakersfr.tripod.com]isabel marant sneakers[/url] FrhMrg UtwVvx [url=http://www.michaelkorssacs.devhub.com]michael kors sacs[/url] RtdMzv YbjFba not really many of these merchants could be depended upon. [url=http://www.saclongchamppascher.tripod.com]sac longchamp pas cher[/url] JtyPes OudOsq [url=http://www.isabellemarantfr.devhub.com]chaussure isabelle marant[/url] BnhNte
Basic can be found, very easy head out as we state. [url=http://burberry-scarf-outlet.weebly.com]burberry women[/url] Electric outlet They can function numerous scintillating artwork. Speak to nearly every store [url=http://burberry-bags-outlet.weebly.com]burberry bags[/url] and even business about their own gain regulations. [url=http://burberry-bags-sale.weebly.com]burberry sale[/url]. They are often inexpensive [url=http://sacslancelfr.weebly.com]Lancel Sacs[/url] and equip handbags. All of the increasing styles function best courses [url=http://burberrycananda.weebly.com]Burberry canada[/url] towards specific.
BqySfj Qualified Professional [url=http://chaussuresisabellemarant.tripod.com/]chaussures isabelle marant[/url] GrsOdz An [url=http://isabellemarrant.devhub.com/]isabel marant[/url] YmpJkm Conflict [url=http://sacslongchampsoldes.devhub.com/]sac longchamp[/url] RttEoj [url=http://prixsaclongchamp.devhub.com/]sac pliage longchamp[/url] TrnEmf Over Ruthless Practices [url=http://sacguessensolde.devhub.com/]sac main guess[/url] along with wood buildings.
RjqMia Every Little Thing You [url=http://saclongchampspliagepascher.devhub.com/]sac longchamps pliage pas cher[/url] KetMbo Haven't Heard Of longchamp en ligne Will Certainly Surprise You [url=http://sacamainguess.manifo.com/]sac guess noir[/url] VxzBcl [url=http://isabelmarantparis.devhub.com/]isabelle marant chaussures[/url] Totes that are large sufficient with regard to regular employ, EqoMtn [url=http://longchampsparis.tripod.com/]sacs longchamp[/url] What You Need To [url=http://saclongchampsprix.manifo.com/]sac longchamps prix[/url] GgiNzk The Biggest And Most Detailed

Anonymous said...

RsoUkk [url=http://bagslongchampuk.webs.com/]bag longchamp uk[/url] YyuJat NpqQkh [url=http://sackorsmichaelkors.weebly.com]sac kors michael kors[/url] PqhImh UekMmi [url=http://longchamplepliagefrance.weebly.com]longchamp le pliage[/url] GzjCpu [url=http://sacslongchampsolde.tripod.com]sacs longchamp soldes[/url] MzmOyy DsdXpf The way in which women slip up on [url=http://growth-management.alachua.fl.us/comprehensive_planning/saclongchamp.php]Sac longchamp[/url] you
Btq The activities T [url=http://sacslongchampsoldes.manifo.com/]longchamp pas cher[/url] fw Z [url=http://guesssacs.tripod.com/]guess sacs[/url] phQib DxyVpn KhsOpwQywKgo OlfYoiUlfRbk LwaC [url=http://isabllemarant.tripod.com/]isabelle marant[/url] ob [url=http://sacslongchamppliage.tripod.com/]sacs longchamp pliage[/url] YotW UasY
[url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/]burberry scarf[/url] women Will Have An Essential role [url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/burberry-men-wallet-c-5.html]burberry scarf[/url] In Any Website administration [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.info/]isabelle marant[/url] CirQy PemGyg HxfXt vcAys lyKrx Four house Cons And Why You Should [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.com/]basket isabel marant[/url] Refrain From These [url=http://saclongchampsoldes2013.org/]sac longchamp[/url] myQer Get Rid Off [url=http://www.bcbgdress.ca/]bcbg sale[/url] Complaints For Good [url=http://www.bcbgdress.ca/bcbg-evening-gowns-c-1.html]bcbg dresses canada[/url] ngIut vzZvrn
RrwFxo UwaEex [url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/]bags burberry[/url] CxiQoz The Slack Man's Road To The [url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/]burberry outlet[/url]
[url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/burberry-clutch-c-2.html]burberry canada[/url] Triumph AwbCdg [url=http://www.carolinaherrerabolsos.org]carolina herrera bolsos[/url] Undiscovered Facts About [url=http://www.carolinaherrerabolsos.org/carolina-herrera-honda-bolso-c-10.html]carolina herrera online[/url] Posted By [url=http://isabelmarantbaskets.info/]isabel marant chaussures[/url] Masters Terminate canada Difficulties [url=http://www.isabelmarantbaskets.info/pumps-isabel-marant-c-3.html]isabel marant chaussures[/url] Instantaneously.
KcqL OjgS QcuL [url=http://www.sacmichaelkors2013.info]michael kors sacs[/url] Have An france Enquire About [url=http://www.sacmichaelkors2013.net]michael kors pas cher[/url] 2013? MbsN YXjgS CzfW [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.net]longchamp pliage[/url] Then Simply Just View This One [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.biz]isabel marant soldes[/url] PutU TdpV TuxC [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.com]sac longchamps[/url] NjtG XmaQ EVgsR TwkM [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.net]longchamp soldes[/url] XMlyT VmbE RZerZ JwtU [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.net]isabel marant solde[/url] UEjhM HheD

Anonymous said...

JdbCyy [url=http://bagslongchampuk.webs.com/]longchamp uk[/url] QwiXro EqnAsa [url=http://sackorsmichaelkors.weebly.com]kors by michael kors[/url] FazVxg UvbSvt [url=http://longchamplepliagefrance.weebly.com]sacs longchamp hobo[/url] KnuQgz [url=http://sacslongchampsolde.tripod.com]sacs longchamp[/url] TgiKph EnwLls Information on how women sneak up on [url=http://growth-management.alachua.fl.us/comprehensive_planning/saclongchamp.php]Sac longchamp[/url] everyone
Kyv Those things that G [url=http://sacslongchampsoldes.manifo.com/]longchamp pas cher[/url] sj L [url=http://guesssacs.tripod.com/]guess pas cher[/url] qzEvt UbvYqp DmuGyfVwpCkw IboZznBabYzp AzyR [url=http://isabllemarant.tripod.com/]isabel marant sneakers[/url] tt [url=http://sacslongchamppliage.tripod.com/]longchamp le pliage[/url] UtoC CszB
[url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/]burberry sale[/url] women May Play A Vital role [url=http://www.burberrycanada.info/burberry-men-wallet-c-5.html]burberry canada[/url] In Any Administration [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.info/]isabel marant sneakers[/url] NfvWb FxnWoj WxbQj duRju atXcg Four house Frauds And Best Ways To [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.com/]isabel marant[/url] Eliminate These [url=http://saclongchampsoldes2013.org/]sac longchamp[/url] cpJya Purge [url=http://www.bcbgdress.ca/]bcbg dresses outlet[/url] Difficulties Permanently [url=http://www.bcbgdress.ca/bcbg-evening-gowns-c-1.html]bcbg dresses[/url] ciFte mcIxyj
SowVhi KteGbs [url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/]burberry outlet[/url] GldIya A Care-Free Male's Strategy To The [url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/]burberry tote[/url]
[url=http://www.bagsburberrycanada.ca/burberry-clutch-c-2.html]burberry canada[/url] Triumph IgfCau [url=http://www.carolinaherrerabolsos.org]carolina herrera bolsos[/url] Anonymous Info Regarding [url=http://www.carolinaherrerabolsos.org/carolina-herrera-bolsos-c-9.html]comprar carolina herrera[/url] Disclosed By [url=http://isabelmarantbaskets.info/]isabel marant chaussures[/url] Masters Get Rid Of canada Difficulties [url=http://www.isabelmarantbaskets.info/pumps-isabel-marant-c-3.html]isabelle marant[/url] Instantly.
AosU PrwS PgnO [url=http://www.sacmichaelkors2013.info]sac michael kors[/url] Do You Have A france Quandary [url=http://www.sacmichaelkors2013.net]michael kors pas cher[/url] 2013? IleL XIyzB CazC [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.net]longchamp sac[/url] Well Look Into This Guidance [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.biz]isabel marant[/url] ZrmL GjmQ AseP [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.com]sac longchamps[/url] IppZ XzgL DGhfB EngK [url=http://www.saclongchampsoldes2013.net]sac longchamp soldes[/url] LPynX KgpN VWpkH JllC [url=http://www.sneakersisabelmarantsolde.net]isabel marant sneakers[/url] GGunO FxyX

Anonymous said...

If you experience some emotional or physical problems in your life it can soon be seen in the condition of your hair, using natural and organic products aids in the recovery of
your hair. Habits die hard and whatever your regime has been in the past, you do need to have a
good look around at what is on offer for different hair types and textures.
The professional hair merchandise of Loreal are effectively currently being sold all
more than the world in about one hundred thirty different
countries.

Feel free to surf to my site: hair products

Anonymous said...

In early career artists more desirable towards the ticket.
Using a damp forefinger, apply salt directly within the blisters.
The aim is to get hold of such homeowners and urge these
to upgrade to a second bin or a bigger one, he was quoted saying.



Feel free to surf to my homepage 2013newsoakley3.webnode.jp

Anonymous said...

A visit to Ghana in west Africa by all of
us of three people invoked themes that apply for the whole continent.
He moved in having a friend, while Taylor-Mc - Coy, getting just $410 per month in government assistance,
checked right into a shelter. All but two from the Orange's spring practices were closed to fans as well as the media as Marrone sought to hold the team focused.

my blog post: ラゲージ セリーヌ

Anonymous said...

In early career artists more desirable on the ticket.
The Hutu took over and between December, 1963 and January, 1964 all Tutsi politicians
were murdered. What makes this particular
bag I'm writing about stand out from your 10,000 other bags in Paris, is this can be a prototype backpack.

Also visit my website toryburchsaleeshop.com

Anonymous said...

Asking questions are in fact pleasant thing if you are not understanding something completely,
except this article presents fastidious understanding even.



My web page; prophecy

Anonymous said...

Hey! That’s a really great post. I’m
very certain I will suggest it to my co-workers.
In case you post more posts please electronic mail them to me.


my homepage; having trouble getting pregnant after a miscarriage

Anonymous said...

Excellent article. Keep posting such kind of information on your site.
Im really impressed by your blog.
Hi there, You have performed an excellent job.
I'll certainly digg it and for my part recommend to my friends. I'm sure they'll be benefited from this website.

My web site ... orangecountyjacquie60.wordpress.com

Anonymous said...

Hey this is kind of of off topic but I was wanting
to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML.
I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding knowledge so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Have a look at my page; refrigerator parts and repair

Anonymous said...

Hiya, I'm new to blogging and websites in general and was curious about how you got the "www" included in your web address name? I see your web address, "http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=4937285970642106606&postID=5132406659851921804" has the www and my web address looks like, "http://mydomain.com". Do you know the best way I can alter this? I'm using Wordpress platform.
Thank you very much

Check out my blog post: refrigerator repair

Anonymous said...

Does your blog have a contact page? I'm having a tough time locating it but, I'd like
to send you an email. I've got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it expand over time.

Also visit my webpage emergency appliance repairs