Friday, May 3, 2013

Consent is not vitiated in all circumstances of sexual assault causing bodily harm

R. v. Zhao, 2013 ONCA 293 requires subjective intention to cause bodily harm before consent for assault bodily harm is vitiated. 

The Court also considered whether (without deciding) vitiation of consent is limited to socially valueless conduct – such as consent fights. Consent might be available as a defence even where bodily harm is intended and caused, as long as the activity has social value – such as intimate (consensual) sexual relations. 

Zhao questions older decisions which made consent no defence in cases involving bondage type sexual activity (see para 79). 

Some might be concerned that allowing consent arguments in sexual assault causing bodily harm matters may allow for the wrongful acquittal of some very nasty characters. Presumably bondage type activity can be measured and if injury is caused by accident a defence raised - here the intentional infliction of bodily harm may be permissible. 

The Court holds:

[107] I do recognize that the articulation in the above guidance uses the term "assault" in the first three steps.  In my view, Gillese J.A.'s decision tree must be read as a whole.  That is, the term "assault", viewed in context, must be taken to mean nothing more than an intentional application of force. It cannot logically mean absence of consent, given the nature of the other steps to be followed.  To suggest otherwise is to misconstrue what Gillese J.A. intended. With this clarification, the test can be broken down as follows:

1.      The jury must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused intentionally applied force to the complainant.

2.      The jury must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the intentional application of force to the complainant took place in circumstances of a sexual nature such as to violate the complainant's sexual integrity.

3.      The jury must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the intentional application of force in circumstances of a sexual nature caused bodily harm.

4.      If in addition to the above three criteria, the jury is satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused intended to inflict bodily harm upon the complainant (a subjective criterion), then consent is irrelevant, and the accused would be found guilty of sexual assault causing bodily harm.

5.       If the jury is not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused intended to cause the complainant bodily harm, then they would need to go on to consider whether they are satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the complainant did not consent to the intentional application of force by the accused.

[108] The test from Quashie, as clarified above, demonstrates that consent is not vitiated in all circumstances of sexual assault causing bodily harm, but instead only in those circumstances where bodily harm was intended and in fact caused.  Where the accused did not intend to cause bodily harm, consent is available as a defence, if bodily harm is inadvertently caused.


Anonymous said...

Very great post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished
to mention that I've truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing on your rss feed and I hope you write once more soon!

my weblog ... click the following webpage

Anonymous said...

Appreciate the recommendation. Let me try it out.

Look at my web-site: working online from home

Anonymous said...

Hey! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the great work!

Also visit my web blog; Natural Cleanse

Anonymous said...

May I simply say what a relief to find an individual who really
understands what they are talking about on the web.
You definitely understand how to bring a problem to light and make
it important. More and more people really need to look at this and understand
this side of your story. I can't believe you are not more popular given that you surely possess the gift.

Feel free to surf to my web blog garcinia cambogia hca

Anonymous said...

I used to be able to find good information from your articles.

Green coffee diet

Anonymous said...

Paragraph writing is also a fun, if you know afterward you can write if not it is
difficult to write.

My website Garcinia Cambogia Fruit

Anonymous said...

Heya i'm for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give something back and help others like you helped me.

my web site :: same day loans

Anonymous said...

Hello! I'm at work surfing around your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the excellent work!

My site :: Adorna Review

Anonymous said...

I visited multiple blogs however the audio quality for audio songs current at this web site is truly superb.

Here is my blog post

Anonymous said...

We appeciate that here on "Consent is not vitiated in all circumstances of sexual assault causing bodily harm".
We are in OC|an Orange County properties.

Here is my weblog; realtor in Orange County explains

Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...;+using+proxy+;+chosen+nickname

Anonymous said...

Your mode of explaining everything in this article is in fact nice, all be capable of easily be aware of it, Thanks a lot.

Also visit my blog ... gucci タッセル 財布

Anonymous said...

toms outlet [url=]toms sko[/url] toms outlet  There is a massive jordan shoes for guards who have finished training and still have law enforcement skills. You feed the fabric through the tape maker and iron it as it emerges. The ground was not level and we were kind of down in a hole and really could not see much of anything. ' You know what happens to collector cars that don't get driven, or maybe even started up? Knowing what their role is, they will be able to see the whole perspective and come up with their own innovative ideas in order to promote growth and wellness in the company.

toms outlet [url=]tiffany italia[/url] toms shoes sale And it is completely free. We will also have BNetRadio tee shirts, bumper stickers and much more for are listeners. This shouldn't be too difficult as this is how I've been eating for most of the last year or more. And while I'm not here today to claim the Apple run is over or that the stock is going lower, there are some issues that need to be discussed. The recovery utility accessible in your system can be utilized to Recover lost data from the USB flash drive.

toms shoes outlet [url=]toms Norge[/url] toms shoes sale Such works have been written from the Baroque period, when the solo concerto form was first developed, up through the present day. In addition, many cases of depression are given birth by substance abuse, rather it be drugs or alcohol. So the bags are not easily broken. While the Flying Shuttle certainly had benefits for weaving, it threw up new challenges. Open A Mortgage CompanyConsumer mortgages are in increased demand.

toms shoes outlet [url=]tiffany prezzi[/url] toms shoes sale  On this day the grounds were covered with white tents with the media present. My favorite is the standard pointy toe 4-inch black heel shoe. Yurika immediately sends the Nadesico into space to give her more room to operate. Scharf is required to reimburse Medicare for this expense out of his settlement recovery proceeds. The toms freeing arm of Disney alone makes the purchase worthwhile for Marvel.