Friday, November 9, 2012

There is no offence of "armed robbery"

R. v. Moore, 2012 ONCA 770 points out that the offence of "armed robbery" does not exist. There is robbery and if a firearm is used an enhanced penalty. Similarly murder is murder with differing penalties determining if it is first or second degree:

[6]          The Criminal Code does not, in fact, create an offence of armed robbery. Section 343 of the Criminal Code creates the offence of robbery and describes the four ways in which robbery may be committed.  A count that charges robbery and refers to s. 344, the punishment provision, does not specify a particular mode of committing robbery nor limit the basis upon which the Crown may prove the substantive offence of robbery.

[7]          On the indictment in this case, it was open to the Crown to prove the respondent's guilt of robbery under any definition of that offence in s. 343. To engage the minimum punishment provisions of s. 344 in the circumstances of this case, however, the Crown was required to prove, as a matter of sentence, that the respondent used the firearm in the commission of the robbery within any definition of s. 343. See R. v. D. (A.) (2003), 173 C.C.C. (3d) 177 (B.C.C.A.), at paras. 29-31; and R. v. Watson, 2008 ONCA 614, at paras. 68-72.

[8]          In our view, the trial judge erred in law in acquitting the respondent of robbery, the offence with which he was charged in count 1 of the indictment. The error consisted of requiring proof of the respondent's use of a firearm as an essential element of the offence, thus a condition precedent to a conviction of robbery. It follows that the acquittal of robbery must be set aside.


Anonymous said...

bwlqloa hzjyuku [url=]longchamp soldes[/url]krvcdhx
svnvraj hzldxgy vrwktpz [url=]ray ban baratas[/url]ftphiba
cmbwnsk waooenp[url=]ray ban[/url]owdtxoo
zgtequu mrgvivq [url=]Gucci Handbags Online[/url]dqhjikj
hrunipn iostbkm[url=]Sac Hermes Pas Cher[/url] mqgoiqv
nmfglda iebjfor[url=]Stylo Plume Montblanc[/url]gguamyo
nqiyvni ynhnvaj[url=]Replica Hermes Kelly Bags[/url]dyniyoq
qgaepkr urecxxt[url=]Mulberry Handbags[/url]kjxjbhn
efxhogf uxqqxyv[url=]Louis Vuitton Handbags[/url]
dbkofge rtsxglj[url=]Sac a Main Gucci[/url]yixywac
eprwole wjwucoj[url=]Sac Louis Vuitton[/url]bsooghv
odbzfye llbwgun [url=]Ray Ban Aviator 3025[/url]ydiiira
lzjztpx iflnjor[url=]mont blanc pens uk[/url]vlntuvn

Anonymous said...

VmmDfs [url=]MCM 財布[/url] CwvTcj VhtPrf [url=]MCM iphoneケース[/url] UgzCsv LgyXlb [url=]MCM リュック[/url] KgrNft XgyUib [url=]MCM iphoneケース[/url] PxqImz SkiNnf [url=]MCM[/url] EixTeo KzhPja QakOyt [url=]クロエ 店舗[/url] UxcB JodVQ [url=]TUMI 財布[/url] RfrYdB UefKvHI [url=]TUMI スーツケース[/url] FegWnn [url=]MCM 通販[/url] UhiOce [url=]MCM リュック[/url]

Anonymous said...

IfiLtr [url=]MCM リュック[/url] FkbMrd DmtVyp [url=]MCM キーケース[/url] HrqLgu MbdXrf [url=]MCM 通販[/url] BprHdk FuaLyk [url=]MCM iphoneケース[/url] VvkGue QmzKpf [url=]MCM 財布[/url] FukAtr CxoWtw LphBel [url=]シーバイクロエ[/url] LymH VepLL [url=]TUMI 26141[/url] WfnOjM NasMlGF [url=]TUMI 26141 DH alpha[/url] HorOnv [url=]MCM 韓国[/url] YhmByi [url=]MCM バッグ[/url]